Rabu, 23 Juni 2010

From the Gallery of Heroes - Maurice Jarre


Movie music is probably among the least appreciated media genres in all of art. Once considered the bailiwick of hacks and drudges--just as screenwriting was once regarded--with the occasional notable exception (i.e., Prokofiev's score for Alexandr Nevsky, or Copland's score for The Red Pony), it wasn't until well into the 1940's that the movie score began to be understood as an integral part of the effect of the cinematic experience, that the static visual aspects, borrowed from the theatre, which had dominated film from its earliest period, were unnecessary limitations; as the technical potentiality of motion, action, and visual excitement evolved, the lyrical accompaniment of inspired music (and sound effects) began to be realized.
 
Though it is primarily a visual medium, film's truest realization is through the marriage of a set of elements, all of which must be coordinated to achieve a unified effect. Film editing, as many have noted, may be as important as any aspect of the process of film production, involving as it does, all the component parts simultaneously. A great movie score can "make" a movie come alive, "interpreting" event and creating a lyrical flow out of the visual narrative. It may be considered as another "character" or motif in a film, commenting upon the action, or suggesting possible meanings, queueing or responding, serving as the audience's "director" or surrogate director's commentary on the audience's behalf.
 
Some movies seem to exist through their primary musical themes, come to be defined as personifying the essential gist of a story. Without these themes, such movies may seem naked, or somehow undefined. Imagine, for instance, how the movies Lawrence of Arabia, or Doctor Zhivago would feel, without the defining lyrical scores with which they are invariably associated. 
 
It may be that movie music occupies a place about mid-way between serious classical, and contemporary pop. Noir movies of the late 1940's and early 1950's, for instance, borrowed heavily from the weary blues and hard-edged urban jazz of the post-War period--a perfect marriage of grit and cynicism which both defined the genre, and dramatized what the music was saying. But the ability to write effective movie music isn't a skill that naturally is adapted from either classical orchestral training, or improvisatory popular styles: It partakes of both, and requires a special intuitive grasp of the subtle coordination between the visuals and he sound.
 
Movie music may be highly artificial, playing against the natural flow of the narrative, or it may be so subtle that you hardly notice it--just a few lingering murmurs underneath the action. The best movie scores seem to express a mixture of predominant statements, combined with the more soto voce mood underlinings or flickers. This allows the composer to foreground some of his more successful themes, while not obtruding upon, or hogging the spotlight. Movie musicals, of course, are in their way more about the music than the action, and usually end up looking pretty silly. Even a film as impressive as West Side Story, for instance, with its jazzy-neo-Stravinsky Bernstein score, makes so many compromises with plausibility--in order to facilitate dance and singing numbers--that it becomes cartoon-like. 
 
There have been many great movie composers over the decades, but none more justifiably honored or appreciated than Maurice Jarre [1924-2009]. A Frenchman, educated in the Conservatoire de Paris, he composed his first movie scores while still in his twenties. Adept as a conductor, as well as a composer, his career in films and television spanned well over 50 years, and netted him three separate academy awards [for Lawrence, Zhivago and A Passage to India]. There have been precious few figures as prolific, or successful, as Jarre in his chosen field.                                  



Jarre's scores were mostly done in France for the first 10 years of his career. It wasn't until he was brought in by producer Sam Spiegel to do the music for David Lean's Lawrence of Arabia [1962], that his name came before the larger international film public. Though Jarre is credited with the score, some of the orchestrations (the setting of the music to specific combinations of instruments, which is highly important in orchestral composition) are credited to Gerard Schumann, and Lawrence Ashmore. Schumann has several movie scores to his own credit, though Ashmore's credits are all in the "support" category. To what degree these two are responsible for the polish of Jarre's score I can't say. Great composers aren't always great orchestrators: Mussorgsky, for instance, whose music is usually considered great, was apparently not adept at scoring his own music; Ravel's version of the complete orchestral version of Pictures From an Exhibition, for instance, is drawn from Mussorgsky's piano version.      
 
 

Aside from the three famous scores I've already mentioned, Jarre composed the music for The Train [1964], The Collector [1965], Is Paris Burning [1966], The Professionals [1966], Grand Prix [1966], Night of the Generals [1967], The Fixer [1968], Isadora [1968], Topaz [1969], Ryan's Daughter [1970], The Man Who Would Be King [1975], The Tin Drum [1979], Winter Kills [1979], Shogun [1980], The Year of Living Dangerously [1982], Witness [1985], Mosquito Coast [1986], No Way Out [1987], Fatal Attraction [1987], Moon Over Parador [1988], Dead Poets Society [1989]--to name just a handful of the more well known! Such a portfolio! 

There are other movie composers whose work I love. Jerry Goldsmith's Patton and Chinatown and L.A. Confidential, Max Steiner's Gone with the Wind and Casablanca, John Barry's Body Heat and the Bond movies, John Dankworth's The Servant and Darling.    

    

Are we missing the point, if we tend to think of movie scores as having a separate, rather than an integral relationship to the medium to which they attach? Can movie scores transcend the cinema to become fully self-contained, stand-alone, complete musical experiences? Obviously so, to judge by the popularity of albums of best-selling scores and out-takes. Occasionally, a piece of popular music can be adapted as is to a movie, as an adjunct or "mate" to the narrative. I've always thought of The Talking Heads' Naive Melody (This Must Be the Place) from the album Speaking in Tongues [1983] which will always be associated in my mind with Oliver Stone's hit Wall Street, which starred Michael Douglas, Charlie Sheen, Daryl Hannah, and Hal Holbrook. In my mind, that music will always be associated with the heady excesses of the first wave of stock market hysteria, America's greedy, larcenous black heart, above which the fluffy, sad, repetitive notes float, mindlessly, a remorseless, remorseful footnote to a dreamy period now long-gone.        

Selasa, 22 Juni 2010

Jon Anderson's Rosebud

 
In a burst of creative energy, the poet Jon Anderson published three books in rapid succession with the University of Pittsburgh Press: Looking for Jonathan [1968], Death & Friends [1970], and In Sepia [1974]. Anderson, who had preceded me at the University of Iowa's Writers' Workshop, graduating in 1968, had belonged to a generation of poets, which included James Tate, among others, whose predominant qualities weren't particularly lyrical in the traditional sense, but more prosaic, confessionalist and self-sufficiently accessible. I.e., the "workshop" poem--clear, sane, serious, committed, balanced and sensible. But Anderson's poems were a little different. There was a fatalism, a more mature cynicism about them, which made their personal poses seem more honest, or daring.
 
I think now I was probably misreading him in my youth, that what I was seeing was cynicism--but I now think, a deliberately strategized cynicism designed to create a mood against which conviction might be implied. A sort of updated Dover Beach, if you will. 
 
Anderson died in October 2007, at age 67, not really young, but somewhat prematurely. After those first three Pittsburgh volumes, his output had slowed considerably, and between about 1980 and 2000, he apparently stopped writing altogether for a while. This wouldn't have surprised anyone familiar with his work. It often seemed as if Anderson were pulling his own guts out in his poems: "These refusals begin to look like courage./You're trying hard not to give in." The trying hard not to give in was the pressure under which he insisted serious writing must occur, a high calling which lent all his poems an aura of inconsolable isolation and disappointment. People, and circumstances, usually didn't live up to their potential.  
 
I never met Anderson, but he did come to read at Iowa in (I think) 1970. A thin, serious guy with long hair (most everyone had long hair in those days). I think Anderson must have been a difficult man to know. Two failed marriages. An exiled New Englander spending his last years down in the Arizona desert. Hard on himself. Hard on other people. But this is mostly speculation.  Unlike a lot of other pretty good poet-teachers, he inspired a lot of students who went on to produce work made possible by the challenge of possibility and commitment he presented to them.
 
One of the poems Anderson read that night in Iowa City has stayed with me over the years. Picking up a copy of In Sepia [1974], I reread it for the first time in many years, and was struck by the different way I remembered it, and how it spoke to me now. Good poems will often change over time, speaking to you in different voices, telling (revealing) new things as your own experience of the world grows, and changes you inside. The poem is about the experience of visiting the Little Big Horn, in Montana, and thinking about the relationship between the white man's stewardship of the earth, and the facts of our own lives in the present. 
 
Here is the poem in full--
 


              Rosebud

There is a place in Montana where the grass stands up two feet,
Yellow grass, white grass, the wind
On it like locust wings & the same shine.
Facing what I think was south, I could see a broad valley
& river, miles into the valley, that looked black & then trees.
To the west was more prairie, darker
Than where we stood, because the clouds
Covered it; a long shadow, like the edge of rain, racing towards us.
We had been driving all day, & the day before through South Dakota
Along the Rosebud, where the Sioux
Are now farmers, & go to school, & look like everyone.
In the reservation town there was a Sioux museum
& 'trading post', some implements inside: a longbow
Of shined wood that lay in its glass case, reflecting light.
The walls were covered with framed photographs.
The Oglala posed in fine dress in front of a few huts,
Some horses nearby: a feeling, even in those photographs
The size of a book, of spaciousness.
I wanted to ask about a Sioux holy man, whose life
I had recently read, & whose vision had gone on hopelessly
Past its time: I believed then that only a great loss
Could make us feel small enough to begin again.
The woman behind the counter
Talked endlessly on; there was no difference I could see
Between us, so I never asked.

                                                     The place in Montana
Was the Greasy Grass where Custer & the Seventh Cavalry fell,
A last important victory for the tribes. We had been driving
All day, hypnotized, & when we got out to enter
The small, flat American tourist center we began to argue.
And later, walking between the dry grass & reading plaques,
My wife made an ironic comment: I believe it hurt the land, not
Intentionally; it was only meant to hold us apart.
Later I read of Benteen & Ross & those who escaped,
But what I felt then was final: lying down, face
Against the warm side of a horse & feeling the lulls endlessly,
The silences just before death. The place might stand for death,
Every loss rejoined in a wide place;
Or it is rest, as it was after the long drive,
Nothing for miles but grass, a long valley to the south
& living in history. Or it is just a way of living
Gone, like our own, every moment.
Because what I have to do daily & what is done to me
Are a number of small indignities, I have to trust that
Many things we say to each other are not intentional,
That every indirect word will accumulate
Over the earth, & now, when we may be approaching
Something final, it seems important not to hurt the land.


The first thing to note is the relaxed, easy language, the meditative calm, recollected in a tranquillity which is deceptively smug on the surface. But no Anderson poem is ever quite as simple as this. Thinking about the place, the event, the poet's memory is overshadowed by the static interference of his marital incompatibility. 
 
"I believed than that only a great loss/Could make us feel small enough to begin again." This appears to refer both to the loss of the Seventh Cavalry on that fateful day in June, 1876, as well as to the speaker's deteriorating marriage. 
 
"A last important victory for the tribes" sounds glib, except that it's a simple statement of fact. Walking among the gravestones on the little rise where Custer's Last Stand occurred, the couple argues. The poet senses a violation, not perhaps to some symbolically stale sentiment--some mawkish respect for the dead--but for our commitment to the fruits of our empty victory over "the tribes." The wife's ironic remark "hurts" the land. Is this an absurdly empty response, a cranky, bitchy jab in the midst of trivial bitterness? 

The remark "was only meant to hold us apart."
 
                                                      The place might stand for death,
Every loss rejoined in a wide place;
Or it is rest, as it was after the long drive,
Nothing for miles but grass, a long valley to the south
& living in history. Or it is just a way of living
Gone, like our own, every moment.

The elegaic tone is subsumed within the larger principle of our passage through time. The defeat at Little Big Horn didn't take place within some remote, inaccessible locus, under the glass of fictionalized fantasy. It was a real event, and the issues and causes which accompanied it are as real, and present, to us, as the report of a battle in Iraq or Afghanistan.    

Because what I have to do daily & what is done to me
Are a number of small indignities, I have to trust that
Many things we say to each other are not intentional,
That every indirect word will accumulate
Over the earth, & now, when we may be approaching
Something final, it seems important not to hurt the land.
 
Every action we take, every word we utter, every deed we do "accumulates" and does not go away, leaves its mark, is "final" and cannot be expunged or excused. "Hurting the land" may mean hurting ourselves, our inheritance, our responsibility to the legacy of our own culture, and that of those we have displaced in our mindless greed to exploit everything, as if it were our birthright to do so. 
 
There have been many books, and many good books, written about Custer, and the Indian Wars, and about The Great Sioux War. But this poem presents the case of the specific event, in the most common of terms, not as a panoramic historical tapestry, replete with documentation of creed and strategic complexity, but in concrete terms, human terms. Superficially, it might read like a failed late Sixties poem about wanting to heal the wounds of conflict, or sewing the rent earth back up after a century of scarring. But step back a little and see how the poem itself is a drama complete unto itself, in which the participants are no more, and no less culpable and trapped within the net of their fate than the original combatants. It "seemed" important not to hurt the land. That seemed puts us at a distinct remove from the feelings of the moment, and throws the whole account into an ironic light. It seemed important that, beyond the ephemeral cares of the moment, the meaning of our history on this sacred ground might transcend the merely careless traffic of our daily lives. Or, conversely, how we act towards one another is just as important as an obscure battle on a windy hill that took place a century or more ago.          

                

Minggu, 20 Juni 2010

Boom Boom Barnbaum



Bruce Barnbaum (1943- ) has been a highly visible black and white fine art landscape photographer, since the appearance of his first ambitious monograph art book, Visual Symphony, in 1986. Visual Symphony was divided into four separate sections, each devoted to a specific set of images: General landscape, cathedral interiors, so-called "slit canyon" abstractions, and modern curtain-wall architectural detail studies. The success of that book was due in large part to Barnbaum's exploitation of the slit canyon work which he was among the first to pursue, overcoming the initial problems of access (these canyons are in remote areas of the Southwest, are dicey places to be inside of, and often require the presence of a second person "on the surface" for insurance), and the high/low contrast issues associated with available (sun)light illumination. 
 
Following in the tradition of Adams in particular, Barnbaum showed himself to be interested primarily in the "big shot" effect, the overpoweringly romantic, loud, over-the-top compositions that usually impress the general public and amateur lovers of dramatic imagery. They weren't subtle, and they weren't intended to be. Barbaum's second book, Tone Poems - Book 1 follows this line of emphasis, carried to even greater lengths, accompanied by a compact disc recording of piano music by one Judith Cohen, intended to elaborate the vein of lyrical abstraction, which Barnbaum clearly feels complements his intentions. 
 
In terms of the market, Barnbaum's work occupies a place about mid-way between the serious classical black and white landscape tradition, and the pop colorists (such as Muench) whose numerous books and calendars pay tribute to the heroic, overarching aspects of wildlands, the starkly exalted places to which photographers are always drawn. Barnbaum is different from these to the degree that he purports to uncover the lyrical, mysterious power of nature. But there is seldom anything subtle about his technique. Barnbaum invariably swings for the fences in his photographs, striving to achieve the most potent, "symphonically" charged compositions from any given subject. Whilst his range of subject-matter isn't rigidly restricted to open, empty landscape(s), his approach always moves in the same, deliberately fee-fie-foe-fum manner towards the biggest statement, the topic sentence of each argument to be drawn from any given circumstance.                    
 
 

 
His slot (or "slit") canyon imagery--which he credits with having resuscitated his career at a point at which his reputation was static and predictable--was taken up with some fanfare in the 1980's, when this subject-matter was fresh and nearly unique. His straight landscape work was then seen in the context of the highly abstract sandstone imagery, which made it seem more ambitious, in its way, than it might otherwise have been perceived. Big shot landscape work, of course, has been around for a century, at least, going all the way back to the late 19th Century. 
   


 
The example of Adams, in seeing the late romantic inspiration in the American landscapes (particularly of the West), has been ubiquitous in its influence. Everyone, it has seemed, wants to make a bigger, a more "enduring" and impressive picture of our dramatic indigenous outback. Though clearly following in this tradition, the work of Barnbaum (in common with others of the tribe of Adams followers) asks to be seen in the context of a sort of
New Age seriousness of purpose, in which mystical or ineffable content speaks wordlessly through an imagery at once attention-getting and filled with "conviction."    


But the gratuitous connection between this visionary empasis (which is perceived as an aspect of the ambitious "bigness" of the prints) and the import of the "message" is compromised by the marketable intensity of the approach. As a careerist or marketing strategy, then, all this sturm and drang on the one hand, accompanied by a philosophical piety of claims for meaning and significance, is probably very astute. But as a viable aesthetic that might stand a little examination, it fails to convince.  
   

It would be rather as if Barnbaum were a composer, all his work would be in a high Beethovenian or Wagnerian mode, which isn't at all an outlandish comparison. In the history of photography, the place of photography considered as a serious medium in which strong human emotion and expression could be represented occurred rather late in the historical progression, happened, indeed, after the first wave of Modernism had taken place in literature, art and thought--after, that is, those other media had already marked out new ground and formal innovation. Strand and Adams and Weston, coming after this, were essentially picking up the threads of late romanticism and reprocessing them at the tail end of High Modernism's brackets (1905-1940). Post-Modernism in photography, wouldn't begin until the mid-1950's, when Sommer and Callahan and others were moving beyond two-dimensional shock and awe, at a time when Modernism had already been pushed aside by Abstract Expressionism, a-tonality, the meta-novel, neo-classicism and Rationalism in architecture, etc. 
 
The pompous banal, characterized by Adams's empty "big" landscapes of the 1940's and 1950's--and the late attempts by him (and his estate) to perpetuate this heroic stereotype of the "great" ecological visionary-genius--was continued, almost without question by his followers and disciples and acolytes. 
        

There is no question that Barnbaum is an impressive craftsman, in the same way that Sexton or a dozen other such figures are, but the aesthetic point has never been about the mastery of a craft, or the ability of a darkroom night-owl to render chemical miracles out of the slosh of developers. The point has always been what the finished image contains, and what we can deduce about it, carefully considered, over time. 
    

The abiding impression which an image of Barnbaum's makes is of a potent ambition, of a bombastic drive towards authoritative command; but the real result of all this emphatic chest-thumping is of ambivalence towards subject-matter in general. If the point of all the images is to impress the viewer with the extremity of their exultation, or awe, or joy, there is no compensating range by which to impute a whole, healthy view of the world. 
     

Imagery as deliberately pushy and gaunt and glowering as this leaves one with the impression that the only artistic response to nature is of grandeur or stupendous determined demonstration. But if awe is all one feels, and wrenching intensity is the only way to express this awe, there is a poverty of human means. 
  
The earth is the result of calamitous forces. The surface of the earth is the evidence of millions of years of upheaval and fearsome, though often in geologically defined time very slow, majestic change. But our response to this record need not be unrelievedly breathtaking, or theatrical. 
 
In historical terms, this kind of response has been done already over and over, overdone, really, to the degree that further elaborations and extensions of the mode have come to seem very redundant. 
 
As a landscape photographer myself, I can hardly claim to be immune from the attractions of the big shot, the panoramic layout that begs to be seen, again and again, or even, given a little luck and energetic pursuit, perhaps for the first time or in an entirely new way. To hold out the potential for increasingly extreme versions of these same perspectives, however, seems a kind of dead-end. 
        
We may always be drawn to the fascinating viewpoint, the vivid example, the unexpected or striking angle. But what we "see" in this opportunity need not be a repetition or rehashing of what others before us perceived. What distinguishes the talented craftsman from the artist is the ability to see differently, to bring to familiar or unfamiliar material a vision that is neither borrowed, nor impulsively forced. It's this ability that made/makes Edward Weston's startling images  as fresh and fascinating as they looked fifty years ago. It's a standard that few bring to the practice of serious photography.   

Kamis, 17 Juni 2010

David Hockney's Cameraworks - Footnote to Cubism??


Cubism was based on the idea--or at least subsequent interpretations and explanations of its meaning and purpose claimed that it was--of the simultaneity of multiple viewpoints of a single scene or object, that the inherent failure of traditional representation (or painting) was that it only captured one static view of three-dimensionality of reality, or of the thing or perspective being portrayed. By breaking a pictorial space up into fragmented, separate planes, it would be possible (so the interpretation goes) to see a thing from multiple viewpoints at the same time. What this of course resulted in was a visually chaotic two-dimensional jumble of intersecting lines and planes, containing recognizable parts of objects and colors arranged in a kind of interlocking puzzle, at once dizzyingly unbalanced and internally conflicted. Out of this abstraction of fragmented visual pieces, a satisfying picture could nevertheless be constructed, using the same principles of balance and tension that were applied to visually normal pictorial representations.
 
Ironically, just as photography was becoming a viable tool in the array of possible media for two dimensional capturing of "real" space, painting was breaking down along the traditional lines of "true" perspective and representation. Could painting "compete" with photography in its reproduction of the visual facts of the world? And with the development of moving pictures (cinematographs), the superiority of sensitized surface exposures was raised to a new level. 
 
If it were possible to reproduce the world (in images)--with great efficiency and rapidity--in all its particularity and flux--did this not make painting (and sculpture) somehow obsolete and antiquated? 
 
Was photographic seeing a superior kind of seeing to painterly interpretations? For decades it was more or less assumed that photography did indeed possess a superior approach to the representation of reality as it is perceived. But the issue about verisimilitude and authenticity is not a simple one, by any means. When we look out of our binocular eyes, what we see is governed by the apparatus of our vision, as well as by how our brain interprets and reconstructs the data which it receives via the nerve pathways. Other land animals, and insects, and fish, to take three other instances, see things differently than we do. A horse, a dragonfly, and an octopus, all have a different "view" of the world than we do, because their visual systems are constructed differently. 
 
When humans with normal vision (20-20) look at a scene, they focus on only one part of it, at one degree of depth. The rest of the surrounding "peripheral" part of the image is present, but is not perceived in the same way by the brain. Brain research tells us that our brains "fill in" or interpolate perspective and "logical" relationships based on training and experience. Our need to know how objects fit into the whole visual field determines how the brain learns to see (constructing predictable and assumed spacial relationships from memory and logic). The relationship between the actual physical world (phenonema) and the model of it which the brain constructs, is impressively congruent. But deducing scientific meanings, or presumptions about the external world, from these relationships, can be problematic (which was one of Wittgenstein's major preoccupations as a philosophical thinker). 
 
When our eyes move about a space, our mind "adjusts" perspective to fit what it assumes is actually being reported. Since we don't possess compound eyes--like a dragonfly does--we are incapable of keeping track of objects outside the parameter of our center of focus. Therefore, our peripheral vision provides a secondary, less reliable stream of verification to the brain about what is going on outside the central radius of focused attention.                  
 
 

Meditating about the failure of both painting, and photography, to report the dynamic interactivity and motion and flickering adjustments of focus and movement which characterize human sight, the British-American painter David Hockney began to tinker with multiple frame photographic images, constructing collages of cut-up photos of the same scene taken from slightly different angles, at slight increments of moment (time), rearranging these rather in the manner that the original Cubists had made their paintings--with multiple views of the same object side-by-side, and skewed angles of perspective. This had the effect of creating a kind of mimicked movement and multiple fractionalization of a single scene. Both time and position were broken up into respective frames. Using rectangular "pieces"--as a metaphor perhaps for multiple brush strokes--he was able to "paint" a scene using pre-imaged fragments, which had the effect of creating an image with duration and multiple viewpoints.  
 
But, rather than being restricted to a recreation (or drawing) of the scene, the photographic fragments (or cut-ups) were derived from real events, real people, real spaces. The manipulation of photographic fragments was the really revolutionary aspect of Hockney's approach, and though it may be seen as the elaboration of a single idea (or trick), he explored several variations of the method.              


It often seems to me, when I look at one of these Hockney photographic collages, that what I am seeing is what the brain sees, or saves from a particular view. If the reality of spacial relationships is actually a distortion of how we think perspective is supposed to appear, it's probably true that our mental apprehension of the world is quite bizarre and irrational, emphasizing certain elements out of proportion to their assumed place, and distorted by emotional influences or incomplete lapsed versions from memory.   

    

The collage-photo above is made out of dozens of photographic rectangles, pushed together in an approximation of the actual structure of the scene. We recognize it for what it is (barely), but the image rests right at the edge of painterly looseness or softness, as if the edges of the rectangular pieces were just subtly off to permit us to "see" it as a work of art, rather than a bland, empty desert scene along a deserted highway.
 
Is this just a screwed-up collage of a plain photograph, or an interesting rearrangement of reality, which tells us something new and interesting about an otherwise blank vision? Is the photographic collage at the top of this blog--of a gathering of friends in the novelist Christopher Isherwood's place in Santa Monica in 1982--a distortion of a scene which could on no account be captured with a normal photographic lens (it would have to have been taken with an extreme wide angle lens which would impose a weird exaggerated depth to the scene), and therefore would have, to preserve our simultaneous view of the whole scene, be made out of just this kind of pieced-together arrangement--an adequate representation of what the seer (Hockney himself, sitting or standing behind the scene with his camera) perceived? As each guest talks, eats, smiles, moves about in his/her seat, listens, or just looks blankly into space, there is a stream of activity which no simple, static, one-size-fits-all approach could ever accurately report.        
 
 
 
In this classic cubist painting by Juan Gris, done in a style which must by now look so predictably abstract and satisfyingly decorative that it hardly elicits a modicum of resistance in the typical viewer, we're given the usual glass-pipe-newspaper-chessboard-settee arrangement, tilted up and made visually "transparent" by the false outlines of superimposed objects. In other words, we've come to "accept" this kind of structural misinterpretation of mass and space and perspective as an aesthetic cliche, just another method of thinking about the relationship between what is perceived, and how we might imagine it is perceived in an artistic way. Its method has entered our backlog of expected, predictable visual styles.  
 
The same might be said of Hockney's photographic collages. As our eyes move over the mosaic of photographic rectangles, constructing a "sequence" of relationships within a given space, we can sense the duration as the time of our visual building of a whole image. The defined measure of this process is built into Hockney's collages, and sets out the limits and parameters of the act of creative human apprehension. We may seldom be aware of how we see spaces, or of how they are saved by the mind, even as we are experiencing them. Hockney's original approach to this problem is a reminder of the unexpectedly complex, and routinely camouflaged, challenge that the act of seeing is.
 
     
 
There is another level of seeing which incorporates both our sense of the time of a place (or scene) and accurately records it in a static present. Joan Miro's masterpiece The Farm [1921-1922]--famously owned by Ernest Hemingway early in his career--is one example of a painting that manages, without much provocative distortion or disjunction, to furnish a sense of memory within objective space. Though highly stylized in its representation of shape and relation, it creates a stage-set of highly abstract power. I've never looked at this painting without being mysteriously moved. The flatness of the stucco wall on the left, the eerie shading of the blue sky, the black hole from which the the tree grows--everything suggests a dream-like recreation of something once known intimately, though not without irony, perhaps even a kind of dread. It is better than straight representation, better than surrealism, better than abstraction per se.   

Sabtu, 12 Juni 2010

Silver Creek & The Return Home


As almost everyone knows, Ernest Hemingway took his own life--by shooting himself in the mouth with both barrels of a shotgun, in 1961--in the little town of Ketchum, in the Sun Valley area of Idaho. Sun Valley had been, and continues to be today, a posh watering-hole for the well-to-do (and in some cases famous), to indulge in skiing or horseback riding or hunting and fishing.
 
I visited the area in the 1970's, exploring notorious fly-fishing venues for the first time. The Nature Conservancy had bought up much of the land surrounding Silver Creek, in the lower valley near Picabo (pronounced by the locals "peek-a-boo"). I've been back several times, and this time I spent 10 days fishing Silver, the Big Wood River, and the Big Lost River over the mountains to the East. The weather this time was fairly uncooperative, and I spent much of the time at Silver sitting on the bank watching dead water, as the insect hatches (and the fish) failed to show much activity.  
 
Nevertheless, I did catch some lovely Rainbow and Brown trout, using 6x leader and flies smaller than size 16. Much of the time, the fish were sipping midge emergers--about a foot to an inch below the surface, at about size 20 or 22--which made tempting them nearly impossible. There were very limited hatches of the larger pale yellow or olive mayflies in size 16 or 18, and this meant most of the anglers were frustrated, or even skunked. The seasonal imbalance, which we had seen in California this year as our Spring was one of the wettest in recent record, was also affecting the Northern Rocky Mountains. Storm after storm rumbled into the valley, whereas just 50 miles to the South, there was no precipitation at all.  
 
         
 
On one of the off-days, we visited the Ernest Hemingway grave in Ketchum, in a graveyard right beside the main highway through town. Beside Hemingway's stone, are identical flat plinths for Mary, EH's widow, and his son John (the "Bumby" of A Moveable Feast). The plainness of the stone--with no inscription or other decoration--struck me as a bit dry.  
 
Sun Valley's reputation was certainly enhanced by Hemingway's having chosen the place to live in for part of each year. According to local legend, he spent a lot of time drinking in the taverns and bars--no surprise since he was a confirmed alcoholic for most of his life. There are a lot of photos of EH shooting game-birds in the Valley, but not too many of him fishing Silver Creek. It was actually the presence of his son John Hemingway, and his efforts on behalf of the Nature Conservancy to secure the area for public access and protection from private development, that has attached the family name and notoriety to the Preserve. The Silver Creek Preserve now hosts tens of thousands of anglers each year, and is famous the world over for its rich stocks of wild trout, and tantalizingly placid spring creek flows.
 
I had two very good days on the Creek, and one wet rainy morning float-tubing just below the bridge, catching an 18" Rainbow who jumped four times high in the air. I got drenched for my trouble, but these dark, roily days are often exciting, especially when there are few anglers on the water. There's a curiously strong sense of satisfaction following a successful day on the water when the weather's rough. It also doesn't hurt to follow this up with a nice shot of Talisker around a roaring fire.
 
My companion Keith Mosier--a friend from several years back--is a self-taught fishing genius, and has parlayed his amateur's knowledge and experience into a genuine expertise. He routinely out-fishes the waves of self-appointed fishing sophisticates who visit his home water, and with only half the investment in expensive equipment. As my unofficial local guide, he enables me to perform with the best of the brigade of professional anglers who frequent the Silver Creek Preserve.  
 
With any luck, we'll have another crack at Henry's Fork of the Snake, some two hundred plus miles away from Sun Valley. Maybe later in the Summer--? 
 
Here's a photo of Keith near the access point to the "S-curves" section of Silver Creek, munching on some trail mix following the mid-day hatch. Here's to a great trip, and many more in the years to come!     


    

Rabu, 26 Mei 2010

Vacation - Long Overdue - Fisherman's Luck




The color picture above was taken at Silver Creek, Idaho, not far from Sun Valley. Literary types will recognize this as Hemingway's last residence, where he committed suicide by shooting himself in the mouth with a shotgun. Hemingway loved to fish Silver Creek, and his son John Hemingway (the "Bumby" of EH's early years in Paris), who lived nearby in his later years, was instrumental in getting the Nature Conservancy to acquire the property bordering the stream, in order to preserve it for fishermen for perpetuity. 
 
Silver Creek is beautiful in a specific way. Located among hayfields, in dry country, almost semi-desert. The air is clear, and the sky is operatic, with big cloud formations, and dramatic sunsets. I've fished here half a dozen times over the last 30 years, and never was disappointed.
 
Once, on a lonely late Summer night, I stubbornly refused to pack it in, and kept casting and casting into pitch dark, just under the downstream side of the little bridge which crosses the stream near the public access point. Big browns were rising excitedly, as they often do just at the end of the evening hatch, when they usually also seem most selective. Suddenly, a huge lunker grabbed my second to last cast. Rising dramatically out of the water, he flew through the air, landing with a great "flop" against the steel brace on the side of the bridge, falling back with a splash into the water, throwing the hook, and summoning an astonished "whooh" out loud from me.  
 
I'm leaving the Bay Area this weekend for two weeks of fishing in Idaho--a long postponed respite from the chores of editing the Collected Eigner, knocking out semi-daily blog essays,  and selling rare books on the internet. I'll resume sometime after the second weekend in June. 

Wish me luck! 
        

Aftermath of Gulf Oil Spill - Confirmations




 
Now, one month and a week after the British Petroleum Gulf Oil Disaster, the company--and the Federal response agencies--still appear to have no clue how to repair the damaged well-head which continues to spew raw crude oil--from one mile down on the ocean floor--into the Gulf of Mexico, and onto the surrounding shore and tidelands. 
 
As I surmised in my previous post of May 2nd, 2010 ["Why Offshore Drilling is a Big Mistake"], there is no reliable scientific or engineering precedent for addressing this kind of disaster, and therefore neither the company, nor the governing agencies, has a clue how to solve the problem. 
 
So-called "assurances" issued by the company's engineers all hinge on the unlikelihood of such an occurrence, in effect saying "this couldn't happen, so we never thought about how to fix it if it ever did." Now that it has happened--as Murphy predicted it would--British Petroleum is scrambling around trying to buy time by making calm, measured, "we're in control of the situation" pronouncements. But it's now a month later, and it seems no closer at this juncture to fixing the problem than it was the day after it occurred.
 
Oceanic conditions at depth present a number of difficulties. There is the problem of access, the ocean pressure at that depth is great, and the machinery needed to manipulate tools and structures at that level simply doesn't exist. Creating an offshore well in deep water is a difficult proposition to begin with. It's much easier simply to set up a drilling bit, and pump up out of the well, than it is to repair it once it's been broken.
 
The petroleum community--the corporations, the engineers, the regulators--everyone knew perfectly well that if this ever happened, they'd have to trouble-shoot a solution, because no methodology for addressing it had ever been developed. 
 
Petroleum mining is a very dirty business, in every sense of that phrase. Oil companies routinely spoil the environments where they work, and the profits they derive from this exploitation insure that the process of oil leasing and permits will rubber-stamp every proposal they present.  
 
The media politely interviews company executives and spokespeople, and the government overseers, and everyone minces gingerly over the embarrassing facts which are brought to light about the shoddy commitments the industry makes to safety. The public wrings its hands, while the ecosystems of the ocean and gulf coast are devastated. 
 
The lesson to learn from this is that offshore petroleum mining is a destructive process, and that those who practice it are cavalier about the welfare of the environment. Bottom line, they have no real standards beyond the profit motive. Of course, we all knew that. What we didn't really want to think about, and what the companies are now embarrassed to have to admit publicly, were the consequences of a major, but predictable, failure of the technology. Now that it has happened, and we've seen how they lied to us, we're in a position to reject their phony assurances.
 
But people are stupid. They don't learn from their mistakes. They hope and pray and play the odds, even when they know the deck is stacked against them. People will gamble even when they know they have almost no chance to win. Eventually, we will license the oil companies to set up rigs all along our coasts, pretending that we've "learned our lesson" and won't make the same mistake twice.  
 
But the lesson here isn't to keep doing the same damn thing again. The lesson is to stop.