Rabu, 21 Juli 2010

Another Valentine to Monsieur Détaché

 
 
che di lor suona sù ne la tua vita 1
 
I walked out, before
"Break of day"
And saw
Four cabins in the hay. 
 
Blue sealed glasses
Of preserves--four--
In the window-sash
In the yard on the bay. 
  
Further:
The waters
At the ramp
Running away. 
 
I have touched briefly before on Zukofsky's principle of the objectification of experience, of how our attempts to represent a feeling or a picture of event inevitably get bound up with the confusion(s) inherent in the senses of words (language) we all carry in our heads--the common consensus among contributors (participants) about what language may be expected to convey notwithstanding, what words may mean (suggest), and how they may function in the discrete context of poetic composition. All the kinds of mediations between the impulse, the act, the artifact and the effect, are active in any Zukofsky poem: i.e., LZ is always striving to anticipate confusion and consolidate it within the echoing ricochets of its possible interpretations. Post-Modern criticism recognizes such problems inherent in the poetic act, including the implication of its own involvement in the process of apprehension. The possible range of responses to any poem is at least as complicated, and separately integrated, as its original inception. 
 
Subjects and objects in poems are no more and no less reliably specific than they are in dreams or film or sound. Cabins and mason-jars and sluices are conveniences in the sense that they stand as inert presences (or in the inertia of time and space)--apart from what we may feel or think about them. Signifiers' reality is thus neither more, nor less transitory than our linguistic understanding of them. Their three-dimensionality--if I may speak of it this way--is an expression of the intersection between two projections--the writer's version, and the reader's version. Both share in the experience through the controlled play of the unfolding of the words (sentences) in time and space--a kind of holographic ghost of our mutual presumptions. Thus the poem's existence points to a third thing: Our experience of the reading of the poem as a mental event, different for each person, has integrity as such.  
 
In the poem--the first in the sequence entitled Anew [1935-1944]--the speaker awakens before dawn ("Break of day") and "sees" "four cabins in the hay." Not in hay, but in the hay. The definite article places the cabins within a context of unreality within which objects may exist without complete fidelity to their characteristics or fundamental nature(s). Cabins may sit in hay; may be sited among hay fields. In what sense are these cabins really cabins? Are they four units in a seaside motel, or toy-houses in a weedy back yard? Their essences as actual things--which the poet may actually have seen, or just imagined, or assigned an arbitrary descriptive to--but their actual existence is secondary to their function within the argument the poem sets up. They, like the words which describe them, and the small, correct (and arbitrary) stanza which contains them, are conveniences whose purpose is subordinate to their function as images (or linguistic place-holders) of things. This is the level of address that one often finds in a LZ poem: Things as they are are not givens, but presences redefined, beyond the general presumption of our familiar recognition of them.  
 
And yet the objects themselves stubbornly resist specific misapprehension. Cabins are still cabins (brown wood, rustic structures of modest size), and hay is still hay (yellow or dull tan, dried, brittle, lightweight, slanting this way and that in Summer). They could be cabins in a Monet painting, wreathed in the dull, grey light of pre-dawn, shadowless, numinous, still. 
 
If it's a bay, it's a bay by water, seen through sealed glasses resting on a window-sill, a bit more domestic than you'd expect in a motel room, but perhaps not. Not seen through the glasses (or jars), which are filled with preserves, but definitely through the gauzy sash to the yard on the bay. Is the yard "on the bay" or does it merely front it? We're looking at the bay. 
 
Beyond the interior of the room in which the window is placed, there is water, running away. But water doesn't "run away," it flows. It goes down, through rivulets in terrain or along courses laid for it. 
 
If poems are objects--and not merely the formal setting of human utterance--their significance acquires a sort of sculptural presence (immanence), as things in themselves. In philosophical terms, transformative or transcendent qualities in all matter (the universe), may be interpreted as a mystical acceptance of the world as a completed phenomena, which is all-consuming and all-inclusive. In other words, all our acts and efforts to place the material world on a different, or subservient level to so-called higher purposes are illusions, or systems of limited applicability (vanity). Art is one way of applying the objectifying brain, through symbolic representation (language), to make new things out of the known. But these new things have integrity of their own, in the same way that objects in nature do. Indeed, words themselves, which precede and largely predate our use and understanding of their qualities, also possess this immanence in and of themselves--and this use and understanding is, at least to some small, measurable degree, different for every person in the world. This uniqueness may seem invisible, until we begin to explore the sense of words beyond their popular definition as derived from our so-called common usage of them. But the use of words in poems (art) carries another dimension of meaning, beyond the accepted, social context within which ordinary communication occurs. 
 
Language in poems stretches meaning and presumption beyond the accepted parameters of defined speech and grammar. The oscillations and distortions of our separate and joint senses of words and phrases, are to a significant degree what make poetry poetry, and not mere speech, or mere raised utterance. Zukofsky's degree of abstraction is located precariously at the margins of the social contract of meaning.              
 
For Zukofsky, objects in a poem function(ed) on two levels: As familiar place-holders for the shared experience of common understanding (and delight), and as collections of talismans in a personal code. Objects sufficient in themselves had been implied by/in Imagism, but an expanded conception of them in poetic composition occurs throughout the work of the Objectivists.
 
This leads into a discussion of the Jewish philosopher Spinoza, and how his thought influences Zukofsky. Spinoza's heretical ideas about the pantheistic, indivisible nature of the material universe as the particular immanence of God--the duality of the One and the All--is adopted by LZ in the division he emphasizes through the titling of his poetic works: A: A Poem of a Life, and All: The Collected Short Poems. The key distinction signaled here, between theOne (the singularity and control associated with a unique life's experience, associations and expression of that life), and the All (the divisible particularities of a common, shared experience of things in the world). These ideas are crucially significant to a consideration of the use of dialectical materialism in Marxian economics and political theory. For Zukofsky, the value and meaning of private experience lay in its unique aesthetic character, but for a canonical socialist, the part the individual plays in society should be considered as subservient to a greater good. The indefinite article A defines the limit of the one, while the definite article nominates the noun sub specie aeternitatis. The irony of the human position, as being both in nature, and capable of imagining a discrete example of external nature (extension) is a riddle one often finds expressed directly or indirectly in Zukofsky's verse.
 
The quotation which precedes the poem proper is from Dante's Divine Comedy, Inferno: Canto IV--
 
E quelli a me: «L’onrata nominanza
che di lor suona sù ne la tua vita,
grazïa acquista in ciel che sì li avanza».

 
translated as-- 
 
And he to me: "The honourable name,
That sounds of them above there in thy life,
Wins grace in Heaven, that so advances them."

 
I'm not a Dante scholar, but the gloss on this passage would refer, I think, to the sacred word in the heavens which guides and blesses those "who honourest every art and science".   
  
Natural phenomena--the quotidian experience of the daily life--may be construed as evidence of the immanence of the sacred in material things. Our apprehension of the magic of ordinary things, relationships and qualities may, or may not, persuade us of the infinite, indivisible or unified nature of the universe. Is our fate therefore ironic, despairing, arbitrary, or inspiring, heroic and transcendent? 
 
As an enumeration of the signs (or symbols) of a material experience, the poem is a riddle about the relationship of language to our conception of the world. If the experience is/was real, to the poet, its significance to the reader will be a proof of the existence and value of that "third thing"--our shared mental experience of reading the poem, and the objects and events it describes will survive the ruthless effacements of time and change. Language--poetry--provides an ideal medium within which to negotiate the differences in our individual experience, and in our experience of language, in all its particularities.             
                                                    
_________
 
1 Trans.:  That sounds of them above there in thy life.

Senin, 19 Juli 2010

We Wuz Robbed !!


The technology of officiating is moving steadily, though reluctantly, towards increasing efficiency and accuracy of calls in professional sports.  
 
The National Football League now routinely uses challenges to permit the use of instant reply to fine tune calls made under the pressure of the moment. Each head coach has a limited number of challenges. No one seems to question the wisdom of permitting some remedy, especially on plays where literally inches can determine the outcome of a game. No one--and football officials are no less human than the rest of us--can be expected to get every detail right, in the heat of the moment, when 22 player are swirling around them.
 
Professional baseball offers some difficult problems for replay challenges. The calling of balls and strikes has traditionally been thought beyond challenge, because there are so many close calls in every game, that to try to set limits on which calls to challenge would be very difficult, and would take away from umpires an authority which might unsettle the delicate balance between the players' natural sentiments, and the umpires' ability to manage the game. 
 
Calls regarding tags on the bases seem particularly well-suited to challenge, since a slowed down sequence on replay can reveal subtle details about an action which cannot be seen in real time, especially if the viewer (the umpire) is at the wrong angle to see them. I don't think there is any doubt that a significant proportion--perhaps 30% of all base path calls--are wrong. There is even general acknowledgment in the media that umpires routinely "give" calls to shortstops and second-basemen on "pass-by" plays at second base because they want to discourage injuries to these fielders in cases where standing on the base would put them at risk from runners coming in high and hard to intimidate them. 
 
Traditionally, the strike zone has been subject to a wide latitude of interpretation throughout the history of the game. It was once thought that American League umpires routinely had a "higher strike" zone than National League umpires, who would call lower strikes than their counterparts. This may well have been true. But the greater difficulty involves the vast difference in the application of the defined zone, from umpire to umpire. The strike zone is officially defined horizontally as the width of home plate, and vertically between the player's knees and the middle of the trunk (or chest). In practice, few umpires call strikes above the player's belt, a clear violation of the rules. In addition, based on the television replays now in general use, umpires clearly are inconsistent about other aspects of the zone. 
 
Yesterday, the Giants beat the New York Mets in the bottom half of the ninth inning, with Travis Ishikawa sliding safely under the tag of Mets' catcher Henry Blanco, as reported by camera shots like the one shown above. Even Blanco admitted that Ishikawa was safe. But home plate umpire Cuzzi, who had been having problems throughout the game, missed the call, and the Giants ended up officially losing the game, simply because the umpire got the call wrong. Games decided this way leave a sour taste in everyone's mouth, even the team benefitting from the gaff. 
 
Instant reply is coming to baseball, and not a moment too soon. It also seems plausible to imagine that a sensitized holographic strike zone may someday be instituted, eliminating, in effect, the need for an umpire to call balls and strikes, except for swing judgments and dropped third strikes.     

Sabtu, 17 Juli 2010

Tom Jones - Prelude to the Swinging Sixties



Tom Jones was probably the most commercially successful of the so-called British New Wave movies. It may be difficult now to understand how unusual it seemed when it first was released [in 1963], because many of its signature innovations were adopted and incorporated into film making practice in the following decades. 
 
The idea of turning a picaresque 18th Century comedic narrative [1749] into an earthy, effervescent cinematic romp was a relatively new idea, at the time. But the film's success--it won Oscars for Best Director (Tony Richardson), Best Film, Best Musical Score, and Best Writing (John Osborne)--with six more nominations to boot--was not only a revelation about the talent of the participants, but a commentary about the changing values of the times. Coming at the beginning of the Sixties, the picture signaled a transformation of sentiment, away from the traditional investment in security, class and duty, to an emerging resurgence of interest in sincerity, freedom and sensual indulgence. It was a movie for its time. 
 
Unlike the gritty, contemporary, socially conscious British flicks of the 1950's and early '60's--Look Back in Anger, Room at the Top, The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner, The Entertainer, Saturday Night and Sunday Morning, A Taste of Honey,The Servant--Tom Jones was a free-for-all in which nearly all the characters seemed to be caricatures of themselves, except, perhaps, for Tom Jones himself, whose good humor, optimistic flair, common kindness and sporting randiness were immediately appealing.
 
Contrasted against Jones/Finney, and brilliantly played, is David Warner's Blifil, the presumed legitimate son of Squire Allworthy. Warner, a seasoned character actor I've appreciated in dozens of roles, including those in The French Lieutenant's Woman, and Titanic, as well as in bit parts of dozens of lesser productions, is the pimply, conniving, sinister architect of Jones's near hanging, who makes your skin crawl with his sneering condescension. I find Susannah York's bland version of Sophie to be rather a disappointment, though she handles the comic scenes well enough. The really juicy secondary parts belong to Hugh Griffith, Allworthy's braying bumpkin neighbor ("more than Gothic ignorance!") who rolls with equal relish among his hogs or his milk-maids; and Dame Edith Evans, nearly translucent with frail age, lunging about uttering pompous pronouncements about nearly everything.            
 
         

Henry Fielding's narrative was an early example of the novel genre, structured as a series of episodes or installments (18 "books" in all), and the omniscient narrative overview tended to objectify the action and distance the reader from the story. In the movie, this narrative position is recreated in the movie as a formal, pontifical voice-over which comments with amused irony and feigned moral disdain on the unfolding plot.   
  
  
 
                                                                Albert Finney in an informal moment
  
As Jones, newcomer Albert Finney was the perfect choice--his beaming, cherubic good looks the ideal expression of Jones's virtuous nature, though susceptible to enticements, always ready for an uninhibited bit of brawl, or a quick roll in the hay. His performance was crucial to the success of the film, and he carries it; almost anyone else would have come off as foppish or just vicariously crass. 
  
 
Hollywood (and Britain's) treatment of period "costume dramas" had been staid and ponderous, for the most part, but swashbuckling adventure films, like Errol Flynn's Robin Hood [1938], or Burt Lancaster's The Crimson Pirate [1952], turned the picaresque genre into matinee cartoons, and treated the historical content as a playground for juvenile tomfoolery. Such fare took complete liberties with verisimilitude and historical accuracy. But sex had never been allowed to rear its ugly head. In Tom Jones, the playboy prototype finally arrived on the screen. Diane Cilento's Molly Seagrim (and Joan Greenwood's Lady Bellaston, and Rosalind Knight's Mrs. Fitzpatrick) are all deliciously aggressive in their pursuit of Jones, and the sheer lack of inhibition belies the "proper" air against which the modern puritanical movie code is played. Jones is a sensualist by nature, and his almost divine incorruptibility which he wears like a halo, is bound to see him through the nastiest scrapes. We rout for him, because we come to feel his joy and excitement at living life with an almost unbridled relish. 
 
The film's use of slapstick--speeded up sequences, the actors addressing amusing asides directly into the camera, the raw bawdiness of country life, lovers caught in compromising positions, mishaps and pratfalls, the masked ball at Vauxhall Gardens ("to see and to be seen, in heaps they come, to do and to be undone")--is broadly indulged. Plotting and intrigue, skullduggery and happy accident, each play a part. And all this is put before us in the spirit of fun, without malice or gloating.
 
Tom Jones paved the way for other historical dramas--Barry Lyndon [1975], for instance, or Rob Roy [1995], or The Legend of Zorro [2005], the BBC miniseries I, Claudius [1976], and Gladiator [2000]--by showing how a central character of mixed morals or conflicting allegiances, with an indulgent nature, could appeal across the spectrum of movie audiences.    
_____________
 
Note: My previous post of December 16, 2009.             

Kamis, 15 Juli 2010

Life is Messy - Art is Cruel

 
Life is messy. Despite our attempts to bring order, in this tiny corner, or in that one, we are overcome by disorder, buried under the casual afflatus, wasted by inconsequential distraction, paralyzed by guilt and embarrassment and the many nagging indignities of the physical reality of existence. We have choices, though, in how to respond to this chaos. We can throw up our hands in despair, or regard life with relaxed amusement. Life may be seen as a dialogue between the competing responses to the meaninglessness of merely being in the world.
 
I was, until recently, unfamiliar with the work of Frederick Seidel. As one who shuns the public literary spotlight, who lives for himself and through himself, without shame or hesitation, he's a man after my own heart. Among the many charges brought against Mr. Seidel, as I read them, are 1 That he was born rich, and has never had to struggle to get along, or even to hold any kind of job, 2 That he likes to live well, and is unembarrassed about his pleasures and fascinations, be they ever so privileged, 3 That his view of life is cynical, often sardonic, and that his expression of this dim view is usually direct, and frank, and frequently gauche, 4 That he enjoys riding motorcycles, and 5 That his poetic style is gruesomely blunt, indelicate, and even at times ostentatiously egoistical.
 
 
 
That anyone who displayed all these supposed faults should be regarded as a superior and entertaining poetic talent is perhaps a sin against good taste, or at least what passes for acceptable behavior in our officiously priggish society. 
 
Literary critics have often mentioned the name of Lowell in connection with Seidel's influences, though the example whose echo I detect--especially in his earlier works--is that of Sylvia Plath, especially the Plath of Ariel. In particular, the air of self-flagellation, the ante-upping daring and double-daring, stripping the emotional gears, pushing the envelope of the permissible, the improbable, the sheer tastelessness of naked outrage--to confront one's deepest obsessions, one's most private conceits, least marketable secret loves and hates and daydreams. 
 
 
 
Browsing through his new Poems 1959-2009 [Farrar Straus & Giroux, 2009], I'm struck by a lack of prosodic progress, of a style of address that's hardly changed over 50 years--perhaps regarded as a fault, by some. Many of the more recent poems do have longer stanzas, and longer lines. Many of them seem more prosaic in their sentiment, as well, welcoming in the explanatory amplification, instead of insisting upon the aphoristic chime of false certitude. One caught my attention, which, after a dozen readings and re-readings, I find to be a fascinating and wickedly well-made poem, just as it is:
 
 
                            WHITE BUTTERFLIES
 
                                               I
 
Clematis paniculata sweetens one side of Howard Street.
White butterflies in pairs flutter over the white flowers.
In white kimonos, giggling and whispering,
The butterflies titter and flutter their silk fans,
End-of-summer cabbage butterflies, in white pairs,
Sweet autumn clematis feeds these delicate souls perfume.
I remember how we met, how shyly.
  
 
                                                 II
 
Four months of drought on the East End ends.
Ten thousand windshield wipers wiping the tears away.
The back roads are black.
The ocean runs around barking under the delicious rain, so happy.
Traditional household cleaners polish the imperial palace floors
Of heaven spotless.  THUNDER.  Cleanliness and order
Bring universal freshness and good sense to the Empire. LIGHTNING.

 
                                                  III
 
I have never had a serious thought in my life on Gibson Lane.
A man turning into cremains is standing on the beach.
I used to walk my dog along the beach.
This afternoon I had to put him down.
Jimmy my boy, my sweetyboy, my Jimmy.
It is night, and outside the house, at eleven o'clock,
The lawn sprinklers come on in the rain. 
 
 
  

A poem like this plays lightly with dramatic concealment, and then releases it with well-timed disclosures. This is an elegy, for a loved pet euthanized; though given the anti-climactic nature of the first stanza, we might think it referred instead to an old flame (as it may well also do). But we don't know about the dog, until after it is so miraculously metaphorized in line 4 of the second stanza ("The ocean runs around barking under the delicious rain, so happy."). And we don't quite know what the tears being cleared by windshield wipers are being shed for, until it is revealed to us. And the self-pity that does eventually overcome the sense of loss, matters less than the clarifying bluster of elemental forces under which the poem, and our time on earth, is made clarified, with the LIGHTNING and the THUNDER, after four months of drought. And the sprinklers, as symbol of our pathetic vanity, throw a fine mist of superfluity under the dark night of eternity (made poignant by the speaker's own mortality "cremains").  
   
The first stanza could almost stand all by itself, a kind of Poundian adaptation from the Chinese. Though this kind of writing isn't by any means unself-conscious, it manages to seem relaxed while at the same time being quite affecting. As one, too, who shares a kindred affection for certain domestic pets, I fully accept the distillate of occasional grief which the poem conveys. 


 

Rabu, 14 Juli 2010

The Night of the Hunter [1955] - American High Gothic Noir

 
 
Davis Grubb [1923-1980] is remembered now as a second-tier novelist, two of whose novels--The Night of the Hunter [1952], and Fools' Parade [1969]--were made into first-run movies. Growing up in West Virginia during the 1930's Depression years, he learned through his mother, a social worker, of the hardships of the poor and dispossesed rural people of the Ohio River region. Grubb's first novel, The Night of the Hunter, which employed this subject-matter, was a signal success, and was adapted to the screen by James Agee (screenplay) and Charles Laughton (in his only directorial effort). 
 
    
                                                                            Davis Grubb (younger)
 
That Laughton's only venture into directing should have resulted in such a stunningly impressive and original production is ironic enough. That Agee (the storied movie critic and prize-winning novelist) should die only two months before the movie was released in July 1955 is doubly ironic; it would only be Agee's second screenplay. 
 
  
                                                                               Davis Grubb (older) 
 
The movie version of the story incorporates several disparate thematic aspects, but clearly belongs within the noir category, both for the severe, evocative quality of its black and white cinematography, and for the stark contrasts of its plot and characterizations. In today's market, the film would probably be dubbed a genre horror thriller (without the gore), but in Agee's and Laughton's hands, it was treated as a surrealist mystery play, with religious, social, psychological, and historical undertones. 
 
      

The plot weaves a number of devices or tropes: There's an Elmer Gantry corrupt "preacher" who has "L O V E" and "H A T E" tattooed to the fingers of his opposite hands. There's a symbolic Huck Finn river drifting sequence involving the two children. 'Thirties social conscience. Gothic rural American values. A heavy sexual guilt motif. Ritual slaying. Child molestation. Economic hardship.   
     

The basic outline of the plot is this: A man robs a bank (Peter Graves), but before he can be apprehended, he hides the money with his two small children, making them promise not to tell where it is. In prison, before he's executed, he shares a cell with Harry Powell (Robert Mitchum), a small-time crooked Preacher who exploits widows. Once released, Powell targets Ben Harper's widow, and sets about trying to get his hands on the money. He marries Willa Harper (Shelley Winters), then cuts her throat and throws her in the river. The children narrowly escape from him by navigating a little rowboat down river. Harry follows on land, and catches up to them, where they've been taken in by a crusading old stepmother Rachel Cooper (Lillian Gish).
 
    
Harry tries to take the children back in the dead of night, but is thwarted by a shotgun-wielding Rachel. The Harper children are saved from harm and the movie ends with a parable-like finality. 
 
   

Like a lot of noir movies, Night of the Hunter exploits both the artistic beauty of effective monochromatic high-contrast settings, and the aura of menace and gloom which the darker shades suggest. Many of the best scenes, especially towards the end of the movie, take place at night, in moonlight, stark street-lamp light.    
 


As a familiar notorious Hollywood "heavy" Mitchum was right in the prime of his career, capable of playing both positive and negative characters with equal ease. Cast here as the shifty, conniving, murderous con-man, his portrait of a twisted psychopath, oozing fake unction and creepy reptilian charm, is classic Mitchum. In the ghastly murder scene, set inside a heavy ecclesiastically apse-like attic bedroom, Powell's ritualistic "cleansing" of Willa by slitting her throat, is like a primitivistic slaughter. We discover that Powell is not only a small-time grifter using his guile to hoodwink simple country-folk, but a wild-eyed pervert enraged by sexual guilt, who sublimates his own self-loathing through the persecution of women.  
     
Winters, as the credulous, devout young housewife plays to her strengths--her simpery, slightly pugnacious naivete. In her death, powerfully represented with her body submerged at the bottom of the river, sitting in an old jalopy, her hair waving hypnotically in the gentle current--she's like a figure out of mythology, a rapt spirit forsaken to death, an orphic sacrifice, angelically calm.            
 
 

As a spiritual force, the river and river country exerts a powerful influence on the course of the narrative. As with Twain's Mississippi, its current moves inexorably, the vehicle by which the orphaned children escape, which carries them ultimately to freedom and cherished family refuge. This is the same holy river of no return that carries Huck and Jim away, it is time and redemption, Eliot's great brown god, the lyrical aquifer of American literature.      
 
     
 
The moral struggle in the world between the temptations of evil and the duty of good, dramatized by Powell's grappling fingers--"old Hate's got the upper hand, now, n' Good's on the ropes"--is the graphic cartoon of ethical hypocrisy.

Agee, who had collaborated with Walker Evans on the famous Now Let Us Praise Famous Men [1941], a ground-breaking, watershed documentation of the poverty of the South during the height of the Depression (and Dust Bowl) years--and was also preoccupied with work on his own posthumously published Pulitzer novel A Death in the Family [1957] which drew on his Tennessee childhood--had a keen sense of the world the movie portrayed. Agee's ambitious, rambling 350 page screen-play adaptation--longer by far than the novel from which it was drawn--had to be thoroughly revised by Laughton. Inspired by the early work of D.W. Griffith, which they had arranged to view in private screenings at the New York Museum of Modern Art, they sought an expressionistic palette of powerful effects to create a noir tapestry of high American Gothic images and scenery, replete with naturalistic detail and an almost biblical quality.
 
            

Indeed, much of the cinematography is medieval in its staginess, especially the scenes at Rachel's farm, where the crude set props--the picket fence, the dark hilly horizon line, the street-lamp, etc.--are intended not to imitate reality, but to evoke a dream-like, deliberately unreal sensation. The cinematographer, Stanley Cortez, had worked with Orson Welles on The Magnificent Ambersons [1942]; and you can see both the influence of Griffith, and Welles in the low-light frames of Night.   
 
Powell's (Mitchum's) repeated singing of the old hymn-tune "Leaning on the Everlasting Arms" as he stalks the children, is like a tolling of doom, a muscular, lustful, almost feral howling (a device often used in drama to suggest the devil). Gary Cooper had been the first choice to play Powell, but he rejected it as potentially damaging to his career image. Mitchum, on the other hand, had a reputation for naughtiness in the public eye. He was the perfect choice. Laughton's distaste for organized religion was shared by Mitchum. His greasy, Bible-thumping Harry Powell is the perfect foil to Rachel's homely, nurturing power.          
 
 

Night of the Hunter was not a commercial success. Perhaps it had too much going for it to appeal to American audiences, traditionally unimpressed with heavily theatrical works like this one. But Laughton's evocation of the brand of stagey "dark theatre" expressionism associated with the Group Theater and Martha Graham's Dance troupe is a hundred times more effective than the busy special effects and gratuitous violence of so much of our cinematic tradition.     

Minggu, 11 Juli 2010

Giants at the Midway Mark


Midseason--at the All Star Break--is a traditional time to take stock of the progress of the home team, to estimate possible outcomes, and record surprises and confirmations. 
 
My last post about the Giants, on May 12, found them at 18-13 [.722]. Since then, they've gone 29-28, in effect losing five games off their pace, and dropping down two places in the standings of the NL West, behind the Pads, Rockies and Dodgers. In late June they went into a nose-dive, and had a disastrous streak in which they lost six games in a row. 
 
What's gone right and what's gone wrong? Well, for one thing, the pitching has come back down to earth. On May 12th, Lincecum, Zito and Cain were all cruising along with ERA's hovering around 2.00. Sanchez wasn't far behind, though somewhat uneven in his separate appearances. People were beginning to say that Zito had finally panned out, following three very mediocre seasons after coming over from the A's with a big multi-year contract. Cain was looking like the solid 2nd or 3rd man in the rotation, the kind of pitcher who eats up innings and is good for 15 wins, year in, year out. Lincecum, though occasionally a little off, was still striking out lots of batters. Wellemeyer was getting bombed, but fifth starters usually are. The bull-pen was treading water, but that starting pitching!...it seemed enough to carry us through, even if the offense was lagging. 
 
Batting-wise, the team looked a little lopsided, with Freddy Sanchez and Renteria on the disabled list, DeRosa about to go on it, Sandoval uncharacteristically not hitting, and Rowand and Molina in numb patches as well. Uribe and Torres were the only good things happening. Fans wanted Posey brought up and put in the line-up, and there was real competition at first base, where Sandoval, Huff, Ishikawa and Posey all needed to play. Something had to give--someone had to go.
 
And that someone was Bengie Molina. Despite Molina's experience and skills at handling pitchers, he'd become a liability in the line-up, hitting into double-plays and striking out with men on base, and letting through more passed-balls than he had a license to. Posey was ready, and management knew it. Bengie was traded to the Texas Rangers at the beginning of July for a reliever, Chris Ray, and a minor league player.         
 

 

Almost immediately, Posey stepped in and took charge, hitting well over .300, and looking like a star in nearly every at bat. Meanwhile, Aubrey Huff, a between-season free agent acquisition who promised some power numbers, began hitting; Freddy Sanchez came back from the DL and hit the ground running, and Pat Burrell (signed on May 29th) stepped right up and began to show some power too. 
 
During the flat streak the second half of June, both the pitching and the hitting went South, with Lincecum, Zito and Cain all taking some beatings, and Sanchez persistently unpredictable as well. The middle relief of Romo, Mota, Affeldt, Runzler, Casilla, and Bautista became suddenly wild and crazy too, and only Brian Wilson--our all star closer--seemed capable of sustained concentration and poise. 
 
After losing three of four to Colorado at the start of the just-completed 11-game road trip, things looked really bleak. But after sweeping the struggling Brewers four straight, and taking two of three from the Nationals, we're breathing a little easier once again, albeit with a number of big question-marks still hovering in the air. Lincecum and Wilson are off to Anaheim for the National League. DeRosa's season (and maybe his career) looks to be over. Runzler will be gone for 6 weeks (at least), but elsewise, the team appears healthy. 
 
       
 
Posey's been a revelation, hitting in the clutch, and for power, and it may not even be out of the question to propose him as a valid candidate for RoY honors. At the very least, he'll make people forget about Molina in a nano-second. 
 
Sandoval remains a mystery. His right-handed numbers are frighteningly low, and his overall approach--swinging at anything close, and often connecting--seems not to be working this year. Either opposing pitchers have figured him out, or maybe he's just a little too overweight, or perhaps (as has been rumored) has some kind of eye condition. At his current pace, he won't have anything like the season he had in 2009. 
 
Lincecum's late-mid-season decline is really worrisome. His velocity is off by about 5 mph, and his control is too. He's been uncharacteristically giving up a fair number of hits, often in early innings, and getting behind in his counts. Despite his 9-4 record, he doesn't look like the same machine he was in 2008 and 2009, when he won the two Cy Youngs. Bochy has tried using rookies to shore things up--Joe Martinez and young Madison Bumgarner (just 20)--but even if he were to get 10 wins out of these kids, it wouldn't help if the fancy four fall off the shelf. 
 
As many commentators have remarked, this team isn't as good as it looked early on, and it wasn't as bad as it seemed during its bad streak in June. However, inconsistency in the starting pitching is going to make the second half a crap-shoot.
  
Hardly anyone talks about this, but my feeling is the Giants coaching staff has not measured up over the last five years, allowing pitchers to lose concentration in games, with hitters showing little discipline. Throwing to the wrong base or overthrowing the cut-off man. Even the base-running has been lousy! Great coaching staffs usually get the best out of their players. Atlanta has a history of picking up players and getting incredible seasons (and careers) out of them. The Giants, on the other hand, have a record of mishandling rookies, and picking up journeymen who play at C+ level for a couple of seasons, then disappear into the tunnel. Renteria and Rowand are looking uncomfortably familiar in this regard. Players in their prime who hit .230 and 10 home runs, or who go 8-12 with ERA's of 5.00, aren't worth wasting much money on. What Huff, Uribe, Sanchez, Rowand, Torres and Burrell do from here on out will determine to a large degree what the 2nd half performance looks like.
 
But pitching has always been the name of the game. If Lincecum/Cain/Zito/Sanchez can pitch up to their potential, then this team could be competitive right up to the last week of the season. I have tickets for a Giants-Padres game towards the end of the season; I hope it's still exciting by then.       

The Limits of Abstraction - the Orient Eye



There are various ways of talking about abstraction. Abstraction is an interesting word. Applied to the plastic arts, it usually means any design or artifact which does not specifically represent a known object or image of some previously existing form. In other words, it rationalizes form. Abstraction may be a derivation of a known form, or it may bear no apparent relation to any known form. 
 
Painters used to have short-hand critical tools for talking about the organization of space within a rectangular canvas. The so-called "Rule of Thirds" describes the organization of masses of shape within a rectangle, measuring the effect(iveness) of a composition by how well the shapes (masses) are distributed among the nine sub-rectangles created by the imposition of a tic-tac-toe grid of four equally placed dividing lines. Do theoretical propositions about the distribution of masses and voids within a given limit give us a meaningful handle on how works of art effect us mentally, emotionally? Perhaps. To what degree are such "rules" self-fulfilling propositions? Another famous handle is the "triangle of light" notion--once applied to photographic imagery. Triangles of light create interest through the inherent imbalance of three end-points, a tension that is unresolved to the perceiving eye, and hence more hypnotically intriguing. Such rules are interesting, but rationally indeterminate. 
 
The images below are made from the same negative. Heaped up "dunes" of sand are classic photographic subject-matter, because they make such wonderful abstractions of light and dark, shade and shape. The sensuality of shifting masses of particles held in mild brief stasis by gravity, consistently altered (moved) by the action of wind. What is the "meaning" of dune imagery? What kinds of visual principles of organization can we apply with any certitude to these varying scallops, scoops, louvres, plaits, slopes, creamy ridges, gaunt seams, sweeping crests, cones and crevasses? What do shapes mean?        
 
  

We can assign programmatic meanings to abstractions, "humanizing" or rationalizing their potential interpretation, but we know this is an application, rather than an inherent measure of their significance. Human is to human as...the tautology seems obvious.
 
This image is one of Brett Weston's more effective, and well known, abstract dune images. During his long career, he made many of these, beginning in the 1930's, at Oceano Dunes, then later at White Sands, New Mexico in the 1940's, and in the ensuing decades. He called many of his abstractions "elegant gorp"--stuff or surfaces that his camera's lens liked: Broken auto glass, warped screens, ice, mud, smashed metal, rock fractures, etc. Dunes are one of the best instances of "found" subject matter occurring naturally in the world. Unaffected by the hand of man, they're perfect, pristine, uncluttered piles of matter, artistically arranged for our visual delectation.    
 
 

One of these images is shown right-side-up, and the other is upside down. It's pretty easy, once you know the riddle. But people looking only at the one on top, without the reference of its correct orientation, might not pick that up so easily. Brett often delighted in confusing the viewer by displaying an abstraction from nature upside down, creating a quandary for the eye. 
 
Which of the images is "correct"? What does the apparent "logical" organization of light and shade tell us about our perception of space? The mind grasps at "keys" to sense orientation. An illogical queue tells the mind that something is awry. An upside down smiling mouth may look peculiar for a second, but we realize quickly what's going on. But with abstraction, this isn't as easy. 
 
Abstract expressionism depends to a significant degree on the effect which subliminal queues create in the mind. Rothko's color field images depend upon the "feeling" certain colors, and groups of colors create in our consciousness. Franz Kline's two-toned arrangements create tension between certain linear relationships in space, without specifying any structural reference. Late Sam Francis images of bubble-like blue and red spheres inspire a release into a floating, synthetic firmament.
 
Which version of Weston's dune do you like best? Do you prefer to have both, or just one. Is it proper to offer an upside down variation of a design which is already fascinating enough, already, without exploiting it further through an artificial manipulation? The choice is yours.