Kamis, 08 Juli 2010

Clear Sailing - A Kool Knew Kocktail



Yacht racing is about the top of the line for expensive sport. Equestrian Polo is up there, but I think yachting is a very rich man's game. Who can play? Larry Ellison.  
 
For the rest of us, we can read about it over drinks.   
  


One of the pleasures of living in the Bay Area, is getting to watch sailboats on the Bay--particularly on weekends. I've never been out, but I know people who do. They come back with dark tans and partially bleached hair. It's a bracing, invigorating pursuit. Better be a good swimmer. 
  

You don't need any lessons to mix this one; it's a snap.  
 
 
By proportion--

5 parts straight vodka
1/2 part orgeat (almond syrup)
1/2 part Goldschlager (cinnamon flavor)
3/4 part fresh lime juice
3/4 part fresh lemon juice
 
--shaken slowly and served straight up in chilled cocktail glasses.
 
 
It has a delicate sweetness that is nothing short of sexy, like the wicked smile of someone you have no resistance against. 
  
Here's the America Cup cup. Big deal....  
 

Senin, 05 Juli 2010

Zukofsky, Fully Baked




When we speak of a writer's immortality, what we usually mean is his/her longevity, extending beyond the boundaries of mortality. If your work lives, then it achieves a kind of timelessness which transcends the ephemeral preoccupations of a given age--it speaks to universal human concerns, to other readers or listeners in other situations or regimes. 
 
But it is also possible to conceive of this immortality as having a temporal interchangeability. By that I mean that a great mind can occur at any time, under any circumstances. We often think that genius shows itself under propitious conditions, that performance is a result of the interaction of character and setting (environment and/or culture), which would support the notion of the uniqueness of the condition or instance. Extending that idea, one might say that a facility for poetic composition, like an ability in mathematics or musical performance or fighting with swords, is transferable to other times, other milieus. 
 
It is sometimes said that Eliot, or Auden, or Hecht might have been excellent poets in the 17th or 18th Centuries, an assessment with which I tend to agree. That is not only an acknowledgment of the kind of poetry these poets write, or of the facility with which they produce it. It is like saying that the skill--the mental aptitude and predisposition--is not necessarily linked to a certain life, or a certain time. It's probably an idle question: What kind of literary person would Samuel Johnson be like, had he been born in 1900 instead of 1709? Of course, he wouldn't have been Samuel Johnson, but another person. But in what sense is the given mind a specific instance of an ability? Would a "modern" Johnson have been a grammarian? A poet? An essayist? A sort of Alexander Woollcott? Or a Harold Bloom? 
 
What I'm suggesting here is a contrary view of the historical perspective regarding the development of political and economic forces, leading to the concept of an historical dialectic of aesthetic form. Zukofsky began as a kind of doctrinaire Communist, like many of his generation, and then underwent a kind of elaboration, not away necessarily from the principles contained in Leftist dogma, but incorporating that set of ideological principles in an increasingly complex view of life and the world. Would he have become (remained) harder Left, had there not been the severe reactions against socialism which occurred in the second half of the 20th Century? Or--more to the point--can we imagine a 19th Century Zukofsky, or a 15th Century Zukofsky? Is there a specific value we can assign to individual aptitude that has a universal applicability? The accident of having been born in a certain time creates a riddle which is unsolvable. Because we can't know how history might treated a certain individual with a given set of aptitudes. 
 
At least in this sense, though, it seems to me that Zukofsky's political persuasions, as distinguished from his approach to composition, have an opportunistic quality--in other words, the economic and philosophical world into which LZ was born, in which he grew up, is in some sense an accident, while his poetic aptitude is a constant, a given ability. In other words, LZ could probably have been a gifted poet in other circumstances. Can we imagine a Zukofsky writing like the Marvell, or the Pope, or the Chaucer? Or the Zukofsky writing like a Shakespeare, or a Jonson? A and the. 

Any or All. Zukofsky wrote a whole book--Bottom: On Shakespeare--to try to convince us of a preference for the clear physical eye over the erring brain. 
 
Ultimately, Zukofsky's defining moment as a thinker puts him beyond dialectical materialism--an eventuality that would seem to support an analysis of him as a kind of classicist. He invokes Shakespeare's vision of love (and perception)--which puts him on the side of science, but not 19th Century science. 20th Century science supports general relativity, genetic variation, psychological and moral relativism, cosmological fatalism (entropy, the big bang), etc. Progress as an ethical basis for economic development is discredited. 
 
Yet there are those who still believe in the concept of progress in the arts. We're making progress by sweeping away prejudice and ignorance. If this is so, then our artists must benefit from the new freedoms from prior limitation, and the improved vantage they have of the past. But a classical view of the interchangeability of genius, and the relativity of viewpoint, suggests that art doesn't necessarily get better, it just progressively runs out of alternatives. Or, our sense of the possible range of formal alternatives must be continually expanded to accommodate our hunger for the new. 


                                Buoy--no, how 
Is it not a question: what
Is this freighter carrying?--
Did smoke blow?--That whistle?--
Of course, commerce will not complete
Anything, yet the harbor traffic is busy,
                                there shall be a complete fragment

Of--

Nothing, look! that gull
Streak the water!
Getting nearer are we,
Hear? count the dissonances,

Shoal? accost--cost
Cost accounting. 
 
 
These early LZ poems are like teasing arguments with necessity, with the prevailing materialistic ideologies of the time. Can we balance the books of poetic justice under a capitalist regime? Is an irregular scheme an incomplete fragment of a larger harmony? Does our labor make us whole, or bereft? 


                Ferry

Gleams, a green lamp
In the fog:
Murmur, in almost
A dialogue

Siren and signal
Siren to signal.

Parts the shore from the fog,
Rise there, tower on tower,
Signs of stray light
And of power.

Siren to signal
Siren to signal.

Hour-gongs and the green
Of the lamp.

Plash. Night. Plash. Sky.
 

Watching the harbor, again, a perfect demonstration of the graphic semblance of commerce, exchange, through the locks of time and permission, the law(s) of intervals, color coded with the semiotics of opportunity. The evidences of "stray" power, of the inefficiency of masses moving through light towards destinations, in the grand accounting of the universal particles. 
 
As we penetrate to the further limits of the microscopic, we seem no closer to a simple explanation of the interaction of bodies, than we do at the macroscopic. The earth is a speck. Meanwhile, what is the price of bread? Whistle a ditty on the way to the corner store. Footsteps echoing on the pavement between canyons of steel and rock. A gull's white shit streaks the fire-escape. There's a cavity in my head. The continent shifts a centimeter towards the East. The old poet moves to a new apartment 14 times. An orient eye has pried thee loose of care.     

Minggu, 04 Juli 2010

Zukofsky, After All

 
Louis Zukofsky's early published work remains, for me, a guidepost to what Modernism means. The usual models held up as examples--Eliot's The Waste Land and Prufrock, Joyce's Portrait and Ulysses, Pound's Cathay and the early Cantos, Stein's Tender Buttons, Hemingway's In Our Time, Yeats's Tower, Woolf's Mrs. Dalloway, Kafka, Musil, H.D., Stevens and so forth--don't capture an essential element of abbreviation, of ellipsis, of the power to suggest and imply and objectify through image and metaphor with the same efficiency that Zukofsky and Oppen and Rakosi and Reznikoff and Williams discovered, separately or severally, in their early work, during the period 1915-1940. That they should, through accident and circumstance, have come to be associated as members of the Objectivist Movement, strikes me as coincidental rather than the result of some social fact of their association. Each was working in relative obscurity--I say relative, because they were obviously, to some degree, aware of influences (some mutual), as well as of each other. But in a true sense, each came by his style independently, not through some imitation of a popular style (or of each other). The poems appearing in the first section of LZ's All: The Collected Short Poems (Norton, 1971) were not collected until 1941, when James A. Decker brought out (the now quite rare) 55 Poems.
  
Here are collected the precious examples of the early, concise, edgy lyrics upon which LZ's career would be founded. Following the long, parodic Poem Beginning "The" are 28 poems which define, for me, the instigations (a word fond to Pound) to a new vision of the world, one consistent with early Modernism in painting and sculpture, architecture and design, music and the dance. Whenever I've grown tired and despair of poetry, or of everyday life, I turn again to these early experimental pieces for inspiration and delight and renewal. 
  
 
Not much more than being,
Thoughts of isolate, beautiful
being at evening, to expect
                                at a river-front:
 
A shaft dims
With a turning wheel;
 
Men work on a jetty
By a broken wagon;
 
Leopard, glowing-spotted,
         The summer river--
Under: The dragon:
 
 
There is no doubt that a good deal has been said about this poem by now; but when I first read it in the late 1960's, that wouldn't have been true. Then, few in the literary--not to speak of the academic--community, were even aware of it at all; which is, I suppose, a measure of the distance that taste and official sanction has traveled in the last 40 years. I can still recall how fresh and uninhibited these lines seemed to me when I first read them. The use of colons, especially the concluding one (!); the skill to imply, covertly, through the recitation of specific, separate, details; the lack of an explanatory framework connecting the dots; the casual, seemingly relaxed mood initiated with the first stanza, the under-stated not much more than being, which sets an atmosphere of warmth, of flickering (smoldering?) lights in the Summer night evoking a dragon (!)--the whole river's body become a sort of leopard or alligator, spotted, striped, alive. The unexpectedness, vividness, indelible surprise and intensity of the concluding image--made anti-climactic by the colon, followed by...nothing. A poem begun in vagueness, extended in visual and material specificity, then transformed with the utmost simplicity and economy of means--all this in such a short poem. Since this lyric is followed in exact order directly by the poem quoted below, I suppose an argument might be made defending LZ's intention to have these poems linked in sequence. Both might be considered incremental impressions of a Summer evening.    
 
  
Coctails
and signs of
"ads"
 
flashing,
light's waterfalls,
Bacchae
among electric lights
 
will swarm the crowds
streamers of the lighted
 
skyscrapers
 
nor tripping
over underbrush
 
but upon pavement
 
and not with thyrsus
shall they prick
 
the body of their loves
but waist to waist
 
laugh out in gyre--
announced then upon stairs,
 
not upon hills,
will be their flight
 
when passed turnstiles,
having dropped
 
coins   
they've sprinted up
 
where on the air (elevated)
waves flash--and out--
 
leap
signaling--lights below      
             
 
This is urban poetry, and the poet pokes fun at classical tropes: Bacchae--female Dionysian followers walking on pavement, not through underbrush, among neon ads for cocktails, not pricking their dates with magic wands but dancing waist to waist, laughing on the stairs (and not on hills). Streamers from skyscrapers! Lights like waterfalls! Stoplights in sequence signaling in waves tens of stories below! This is as good as Gershwyn! Think of O'Keeffe's vision of New York skyscrapers--      
 
 
 
 
This delicately ironic bacchanalian lyric of the modern city may seem half-serious, but it's so much more up-to-date than anything being written at the time (early- or mid-20's) about American city life. That dragon, those Flappers, all that electricity and commerce (the river)--all that artificial light and streamers and highrise skyscrapers. How shall the tropes of ancient Greek poetry be reinterpreted--re-ignited--twenty centuries later?  
 
For me, it isn't J. Alfred Prufrock or Peter Quince or Stephen Dedalus who personify the effects and atmosphere of the modern world, but the direct representations of the Objectivists--the insistence upon materiality, the incorporation of contemporary language, concision and density, a lack of "filler" or redundant connectedness--no formal decorativeness.
 
The sincerity which was so dear to the Objectivists has to do, in my view, with an investiture in emotion (sentiment) that bears some literal connection to real situations and real people, instead of mythical, ideal or imaginary ones; in economic and material realities of the present, instead of those borrowed from mythology or legend or folklore, or from idealized versions of character or society. But it isn't just the acknowledgment of these things, that matters, but how they are seen. There is an energy transfer from phenomena, an eccentric design in space, which no ready-made traditional artificial formal pattern can describe. Thus, art must respond to this eccentricity or uniqueness of the world, in its particulars, in a way that respects its structure and formula, rather than imposing a posterior order upon it. In this respect, it is empirical, building from specific to general, rather than top down, deductively, forcing subject matter to conform to pre-conceived principles of order.           
  
For me, Zukofsky's All: the collected short poems 1923-1964 is a textbook of examples, the obvious work of a genius, and a feast for the mind. LZ could have written in any time, under any cultural paradigm.       

Sabtu, 03 Juli 2010

Weird (Mis-) Conceptions about Poetry





I'm continually amused at the way people think conceptually about poetry in general. It's almost a catalogue of misconceptions. 

Americans, especially--who seem timid, perhaps even a little afraid of what poetry implies, or might reveal to them about themselves, or the world--frequently have very odd notions about what poetry does, or where it originates, or what its value might be to them.
  
Much of the confusion comes from early associations. As children, we are frequently read nursery rhymes. Nursery rhymes--an old Victorian institution--are intended to catch children's attention, to delight their immature ears with the clanging, clicking congruence of rhythm and rhyme; it's supposed to be easy, and is usually condescending and silly. Lewis Carroll and Edward Lear made "nonsense" poetry popular.
 
Then there's church or religious poetry--from the Bible, and hymn tunes. Most people raised in religious families first encountered "serious" poetry in church. The Psalms, and the familiar rhetorical poetry of the King James Version. 
 
These typical early exposures to "poetry" put troubling preconceptions into the minds of children from their earliest awareness of language. Has anyone ever given any thought to how powerful these early influences are on our sense of what poetry is, and should be, or could be?
 
Rhyme, it seems to me, is--if looked at dispassionately and without prejudice--a quite sophomoric and idiotic kind of game. Even when it is done magnificently and joyously by Shakespeare, or Donne, there is a kind of absurdity in end-rhyme. How would we be likely to view it, if we hadn't been indoctrinated, in childhood, with the hoary old warhorses like Winnie the Pooh, or Mother Goose, or A Child's Garden of Verses? The association, in childhood, with bad, puerile verses, probably does more to corrupt our minds about poetry, than anything else.  
 
One often hears people talk about poetry as if it were a "sacred" thing. People will speak in hushed tones, or with reverence about Rumi, or St. John of the Cross, or even Manley Hopkins, as if the fact of their orientation with religious themes somehow made poetry synonymous with religious inspiration. There are certainly good reasons to see any kind of art as faith-inspired, but to presume that all poetry is, or should be, religious is really a dumb idea.
 
Poetry and song, poetry and performance (theatre), poetry and games, poetry and private meditation, poetry and knowledge (Lucretius)--there are so many other kinds of associations possible. What would happen if we waited until, say, age 17 to read poetry? What would happen if we didn't read "children's" poetry to children? What would happen if we didn't read poetry in church? I've often thought that our responses to poetry might be so much more balanced and rational, if we weren't subjected to the indoctrinations of childhood. 
 
Is is possible to imagine a setting in which such orientations did not occur? Probably futile to imagine it. What would we think of William Carlos Williams, or Thoreau, or Whitman, if we hadn't already, by the time we first read these writers' works, been subjected to the patter of nursury rhymes and church hymns? Might we not find them much more interesting than the tame couplets and quatrains of a hundred tinkering rhymsters? Might not rhyme be viewed--as I believe it ought to be--as a not-very-interesting parlor trick applied to language?          

Jumat, 02 Juli 2010

Merwin as Laureate


The appointment of W.S. Merwin to the post of Poet Laureate must come as a kind of anti-climax at this point. Having won nearly every award, grant, prize, fellowship and accolade for which an American poet can qualify, Merwin can claim (after 50 years of it, as few ever could) to be a successful, full-time, professional poet.
 
His collected poems must run to well over 2000 pages (!) at this point. One might well ask, with justice, how anyone, no matter how talented and lucky, could expect to continue over a long lifetime (Merwin is now 82) to produce enough good work to justify all that prolificity. And that's not all! He has also found the time to produce at least six full collections of stories and prose recollection, in addition to nearly 30 books of translations. No surprise, then, that he hasn't spent nearly as much time teaching as many of his contemporaries, having devoted more effort towards supporting himself through translation work. 
         

Merwin, then, looks a lot more like the old-fashioned European model of man-of-letters, than he does the opportunistic, flash-in-the-pan, American version: A dedicated worker, doggedly churning out product, keeping out of the spotlight, refraining from taking publicly unpopular views, and generally maintaining a low profile.   
 
Ordinarily, a writer whose career began, as Merwin's did, with immediate recognition (he won the Yale Prize in 1952, at the age of 24), proceeds to produce another half-dozen books, and a sheaf of essays, perhaps a verse play, and then folds his tent. But Merwin kept on writing and writing.... By 1967, when his "break-out" book, The Lice, was published by Atheneum, he looked to be well into his late period, his "mature" fulfillment. (Actually, I've always thought it was his previous book, The Moving Target [Atheneum, 1963], that signaled his real departure from the academic and staid style of his early period, but no matter.) The Carrier of Ladders [1970], and Writings to an Unfinished Accompaniment [1973] merely extended and elaborated the gains in the manner of the previous two books.
 
There was some doubt at the time, about the extent to which Merwin had really transformed himself with this sequence of books. How genuine, in other words, was Merwin's attempt to remake himself into the counter-cultural guru which the age (the 1960's) demanded? Bly, Wright, Kinnell, Rich, Hecht, Simpson, Justice, et al, had tried to accommodate their manner and means to the relaxed atmosphere of that period--with varying degrees of success. 
 
In my view, Merwin's self-renewal was probably among the least convincing of the lot. The generality of his subject-matter--always safely "classical" or remote (European)--and its fashionably (though politely vague) liberal bias always struck me as safe and timid. As book after book after book continued to be added to the already groaning shelf of titles, one began to wonder at his agenda, as if just the process of generating more matter were some proof of worth. Merwin has published fully 14 collections of verse since The Lice, and shows no signs of slowing, even now. After Writings to an Unfinished Accompaniment (clever title, that...) I decided that his work was no longer of much interest: The style seemed fixed, and there didn't seem to be an argument behind any of his poems. I can do it again, and again, and maybe the next one will be better.... In some media, this kind of persistence is useful. For instance, in photography, Brett Weston was rumored to have produced several thousand finished negatives, all of which he burned shortly before his death, in order to prevent others from "interpreting" them in the future. And Harry Callahan continued to make exposures, thousands of which he never believed should ever be perfected and shown. But photography is a different kind of act--you don't know what you've "got" until it floats in the tray. 
 
            

Writing, however, is another thing altogether. A book of poems--representing a period of between 6 months (Sylvia Plath's Ariel was the work of, I think, just a couple of months) and perhaps 5 years, should summarize a period of concern and awareness that defines an attitude and an approach to form that is compelling enough to warrant the process of editing and finishing and publishing. A book of poems should not simply be an annual or bi-annual report, rehashing the same data and conclusions, in the same manner as previously. Aesthetic productions are not boxes of cereal or software updates. A poem, a book, a painting, a song, a room--these should be unique and persuasive enough--and challenging--on their own, to demand the test of appreciation and value. 
 
A light verse hack like Odgen Nash could with justice crank out a couple of thousand pages of dopey rhymes. People who have an appetite for that stuff could wade through it to their heart's desire. But serious poetry requires a greater concentration, a sense of necessity which becomes dilute if hurried or indulged in too liberally. George Oppen's work, in Discrete Series, The Materials and This in Which, always struck me as complete. Of Being Numerous, Seascape and Primitive, for my taste, don't add much to the total effect of his work. 
 
Merwin himself, in one of his most telling moods, actually wrote a poem (included in The Moving Target) about wanting his work to be driven by "necessity" rather than opportunity or vanity or ambition. But he didn't follow his own injunction. He kept on publishing--and submitting--his work endlessly. 
 
Merwin was showcased last night on PBS's The NewsHour (formerly The Jim Lehrer News Hour), and he was as usual polite, a bit intriguing, and a little faint in his impression. He read a poem about his mother--a pretty good poem, actually--while sitting on a stair-case on the street. 
 
 
Rain Light
 
All day the stars watch from long ago
my mother said I am going now
when you are alone you will be all right
whether or not you know you will know
look at the old house in the dawn rain
all the flowers are forms of water
the sun reminds them through a white cloud
touches the patchwork spread on the hill
the washed colors of the afterlife
that lived there long before you were born
see how they wake without a question
even though the whole world is burning
 
 
--which is really not bad at all, though it exhibits all the usual faults of a mature Merwin poem: The droning, the lack of a conversational variance in the tone of voice, the personification of a vague figure "mother" with a gratuitous confusion between what she is allegedly saying and what the poet is evoking, the vagueness of the images, the slackness of the language (none of the lines is particularly memorable in phrasing or sound). Withal, it is a very "nice" poem, with three or four touches--but what are the "washed colors of the afterlife"? The whole experience of the poem is of a series of soft, vague, shifting movements or non-specific impressions, no one of which is very memorable, all of which contribute to a kind of echo of a possible conception of a poem, the stuff of a possible poem, were the poet inclined to polish it and raise it to the level of inspired utterance. Merwin was careful to second the interviewer's query about putting poems into "commonplace" language; but we have every right to demand that a poet with Merwin's facility put more into his work than everyday language. 
 
There has to be more inside a poem than what Merwin gives us. These rocking-chair poems, sitting on the porch in early Autumn, blandly apostrophizing from memory, the remote sentiments of a previous time--are not good enough. We demand more from poetry than this.
    
               

Kamis, 01 Juli 2010

The Paris Review - The Life & Death of a Famous Literary Rag



Did it not always seem a little strange, gentle reader, that the primary support of the most famous serious literary periodical in the Western World, The Paris Review, should emanate from one Sadruddin Aga Khan, a scion of a wealthy royal (Iranian) family residing in Europe? With the revelations which have come to light regarding the origins of what had always, over the years, been referred to as "George Plimpton's magazine," it all seems to make perfect sense. 
 
Following accounts in the press since Plimpton's death, it's now been revealed that the original "founders" of the Paris Review were Thomas H. Guinzburg and Harold L. Humes, but that control was wrested away from these two by none other than Peter Matthiessen, acting on the behalf, and as an agent, of the American Central Intelligence Agency. Apparently, Plimpton too was connected with the CIA, and his name appears on the masthead of issue #1, instead of that of Humes (the original chief editor). Most of the important figures at the magazine had been connected in one way or another, either at college, or in the New York publishing world, but the CIA connection still seems an astonishing revelation, given the apparent serious nature of the magazine.
 
      
 
But perhaps not so surprising after all. In the immediate post-War years, at the height of the Cold War, when international political suspicion and paranoia was at its height, the American CIA had, apparently, been clandestinely supporting any and every kind of favorable subversive activity, in an attempt to influence the European community (as well as those on the home front) to look favorably upon anything positive (even in a literary sense) which might be associated with Western ideals. Situated in Paris, The Paris Review, which was in every sense of the word except perhaps a legal one, an American publication, seemed very much the kind of preppy, cheerful, up-to-date cultural organ that the CIA liked, and it apparently pumped support money through a shell foundation named after the Aga Khan, to keep it afloat. That it could not have managed to survive without this kind of support probably comes as no surprise to those in the periodical industry. Even in its heyday, the "little [literary] magazine" was never a prosperous enterprise.   
 
 
 
I remember the first issue of The Paris Review I ever bought and read. It was issue #41, the Nabokov Interview issue, and it had poems by Philip Whalen and John Ashbery. I've never been that into experimental fiction, and for some years I couldn't make heads or tails of the fiction I read in PR, but Tom Clark had been the Poetry Editor for some while by 1967, and though I didn't know it at the time, his selections put me right into the thick of the avant garde poetry scene of the mid-1960's: Other selections in this issue included poems by Bill Berkson (whose collected early poems, Blue Is The Hero, would be the first major title of my small press, L Publications), Dick Gallup, Barbara Guest, Kenneth Koch, Frank Lima, Ron Padgett, James Schuyler and Tony Towle. As I was to learn later, these figures mostly belonged to the first or second generation of the so-called New York School. 
 
I knew nothing, then, of the literary issues involved in these kinds of selections, or anything about the history of The Paris Review. What was apparent was that the magazine was a sophisticated, professionally edited magazine devoted to showcasing new kinds of writing, and that as odd and peculiar as that writing might seem, I knew that it was I who was not up to date, not the magazine.
   

It's my theory that every magazine has a certain life, a certain course of development over time. Literary magazines inevitably reflect the taste and persuasions of their editors, and no one can like or prefer everything at once. Editorial practice involves choices, and you can't please everybody. The Paris Review was clearly devoted to discovering and publishing the newest, most audacious and innovative writing it could find--that much was plain. 
 
How this policy could have thrived, despite being fronted by an international counter-intelligence agency, is a question for another day. But thrive it did, and it continues today, albeit in a very different form, and under a regime with very different goals, than those it began with in 1953. 
 
The look and feel of periodicals changes over time. Magazine publication isn't a static thing, and design, typography, paper and binding procedures gradually are transformed by taste and technology. I have a complete run of The Paris Review of issues #1 through #60. The format of issue #1 pictured above stayed fairly constant throughout the first twenty-something issues, then began to change. The page size stayed fairly constant up until a couple of years ago, when it was slightly enlarged. Some time in the 1970's, the lovely paper and signature binding was abandoned, and the cover designs began to look pretty dull. The early years featured cover designs by important artists that were so popular, that poster reproductions of them were typically on sale, and even traded on the collectible market. Back issues, which used to be advertised on the back cover of the magazine, were also collectible.  
 
      

The editorial masthead changed over time, too. In the early years, the poet and teacher Donald Hall edited the poetry department. After several years, this passed to X.J. Kennedy, a rather academic figure whose choices were fairly conservative. Then, in 1963, Tom Clark was chosen to replace him, and for a good long while, perhaps seven years, his choices were really top-notch. Then Tom's choices began to seem a bit questionable, and in 1973 he was removed in favor of...was it Richard Howard? I'm not sure. In any case, things did change considerably.
 
   

But my real point in discussing The Paris Review is to suggest, once more, as I have in the past, that a magazine has a certain life. Truly small magazines may have a life which reflects the amount of conviction and energy which go into their production. Periodicals with institutional backing may go on wobbling around for decades, with successive generations of editors and sub-editors and staffs following each other in a dull order. 
 
An inspired literary magazine can't simply believe in "good" writing or "literature"--it must have a point of view, an axe to grind. Without this kind of attitude, it's not likely to have a clear measure of choice in its selections. Middle-brow literary ventures tend to be very dull, whether they're workshops, publishers, periodicals, prize contests, or readings and conferences. A vision of something specific may be half-baked, radical, eccentric or wild-eyed, but this is always better than simply announcing "quality" or "good taste" or "eclectic" as criteria. The selections that appeared in The Paris Review during its first 15 years or so of life were no better, or worse, than the editorial vision of its editors, and these changed over time. The Interview feature, now in its 57th year, has undoubtedly been the most popular and useful of the magazine's content over the decades. One of its most famous was the Hemingway Interview, conducted by George Plimpton himself, for the 1958 issue #18 (pictured above).
      
  

For me, The Paris Review ceased to be interesting somewhere along in the mid-1970's, at about the time that Tom Clark left, and the original paper/binding/cover format began to change too. But Clark's departure did not become the occasion of a revision of the "new"--as if a younger rank of writers was coming aboard. On the contrary, it was an opportunity to turn back the clock on taste, returning the magazine to the early days of its inception in the 1950's. Richard Howard, for instance, could hardly be considered, by any stretch of the imagination, as an avatar of avant garde literary taste. 
 
In my view, then, by, perhaps, 1975 or so, the magazine had simply run out of steam. Its editorial choices had ceased by then to represent experimentation and risk, and simply reflected accepted notions of "fine writing" which were as commonplace as they had been 25 years before. One no longer opened The Paris Review with any expectation of reading unusual prose or challenging verse; it simply wasn't being published there any more; and that's been largely true ever since. 
      

Magazines begin in optimistic fervor, and continue for a while, and then die. This is inevitable. Every generation has its new version of itself. Today, online magazines like Slate and Jacket seem much more important than material text versions. The costs and distribution issues associated with publication of paper magazines and journals will soon make them untenable, as these same trends have impacted newspapers and general interest periodicals. But The Paris Review died a long time ago--it has just had to wait a few more years to be finally put to rest.

The Mehserle Verdict



At the Compass Rose, one of our firm convictions is that the new Taser weapon technology was a very bad idea from the start, and the trend across the nation of adopting these new "stun" guns for common use by municipal police department forces in the field opens a whole new sphere for potential abuse of legal authority.
 
In the Mehserle case, a young, inexperienced Bay Area Rapid Transit officer was called into a scene as a back-up, to assist in quelling a near-riot on the Oakland Line train and platform. When he arrived, the situation was only partially resolved, and several obstreperous young African American males, identified as primary participants in the melee, were in the process of being detained, and arrested. Mehserle was not aware of whether these men were armed or unarmed, and in the general confusion, with BART patrons screaming and milling about very nearby, the situation verged on chaos. At any moment, members of the crowd might riot, and given this tension, if any of the young hooligans involved in the incident had been armed, any or all of the officers would have been at great risk. 
  
I am not a lawyer, and I can't debate the various remedies proposed by the Prosecution or Judge in Los Angeles. Apparently, the jury has been instructed to waive a possible Murder One conviction, since Mehserle could not be shown to have premeditated the act. However, there appear to be a couple of obvious things to note.
 
1) Mehserle did not intend to shoot Grant with his pistol. You would have to believe that Mehserle was either mentally deranged--a diagnosis that no one (including the Prosecution) has suggested--or that, under the pressure of the moment, he simply went haywire and, in full view of his fellow officers, and a large crowd of witnesses, he "decided" to use lethal force. A mental incapacity defense might have been one possible choice among those available to Mehserle, but it was decided not to employ this, since Mehserle had no history of mental instability.   
 
2) Given his behavior at the scene of the crime, stating his complete surprise in the confusion of the moment that he had in fact shot Grant with his pistol, instead of his Taser, it's inconsistent with a belief that he acted deliberately and with malice. It's much more likely, given the circumstances, that he mistook his service revolver for his Taser weapon, and used one thinking it was the other.      
 
 
 
Locally, there's been a good deal of public sentiment directed at Mehserle. The African American community has risen up in protest against what it sees as a "racist" act of violence, and has threatened to riot if the verdict doesn't satisfy their sense of justice. I find this all a little odd.
  
Following the O.J. Simpson trial in 1995, public sentiment was neatly divided along racial lines. The White community believed that Simpson had escaped justice, in being found not guilty on technical grounds (for the premeditated knifing murder of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman). Though Simpson had clearly done the deed (blood of the victims was found in his car), the African American community preferred to think that justice had been served, and were satisfied that one of their own could get away with a crime, just as they believed white people routinely did in our system of justice. It didn't seem to concern them that systemic corruption isn't made all right by performing more corruption within the system.
  
Having tried Mehserle and found him guilty, the African American community now apparently wants to see real "justice" in the form of a murder conviction, and if they don't get it they've threatened to riot in protest. Business owners and public service establishments in Oakland are preparing for the worst, nailing up plywood barriers over their street fronts. 
  
Personally, I don't think Mehserle intended to kill Oscar Grant. If he had wanted to disable Grant, he could obviously have shot him in the leg or shoulder; shooting him directly in the back supports his allegation that he was using the stun gun, and not his pistol. I think of him as a victim of circumstances, and guilty (at most) of poor judgment, or perhaps poor performance. But Oscar Grant--despite what you may think of him as a man--did not deserve to die--in the way he did---even if he had been packing a weapon. An involuntary manslaughter conviction is probably the best outcome we could hope for here.      
    


 
But the real issue here is the use of Tasers. Even if you believe that Mehserle's testimony about his confusion between weapons is a fabrication, it's a fabrication built upon opportunity, and that opportunity was made possible by the department's policy of authorizing the carrying of Tasers by its officers.  
  
As long as these dangerous toys continue to be used by officers in the street, there will be abuse of them, and further instances of the kind of "confusion" that happened in the Mehserle case.  
 
Tasers must be outlawed!