Selasa, 12 Januari 2010

Two Early Poems by Barrett Watten - A Post-Structuralist View

 
       

  
The following two poems appeared first in L Issue #1, in 1972, a poetry magazine which I edited. They are interesting primarily because of the directions which Barrett Watten's work would take in the succeeding decades, long after he had been associated with the Iowa Writers' Workshop, where these poems were written. (Personally, I've always liked them, and think of them as among Barry's best work, though I doubt this is an opinion he shares.)  
 
 
 
the moon is in the fan
Tropicana
 
Wallace line indigo limelight
 
vermouth
 
                that crushed metallic
writing on black velvet
 
Nicaragua
  
            beautiful
let me blow it
 
Bodega Bay 

  
_____________
 
 
 
Natura Morta
 
 
palm fronds
 
*
Russian
bottles
 
*
my daughter
 
* 
my late
daughter
 
*
my late
daughter's 
pettiness
 
*
winter
window
 
*
 l'express
 
*
specimen
specie
specific
spectacular
 
*
spectacular
ornate
 
*
edge
 
*
im-
material
dark edge
 
 
_____________ 
 
 
These two early poems, which succeed by about one year the Author's first self-published pamphlet Radio Day in Soma City [Iowa City, 1971] show a more focused vision, albeit in an apprentice setting, than his earlier attempts, for instance, at appropriating the pop styles of Ted Berrigan or Anselm Hollo. 
 
On the most basic level, these poems can be read as attempts to objectify the sign, in the service of an investiture in a trumping irony, or as a contempt for aesthetic contexts from which cliche'd traditional literary models derive--as an exercise in critical dismantling. The speaker disengages from the jeopardy of an implied (narrative of) imitation, in order to distance himself from those sources--their limitation(s) of sentiment. 
 
Whereas Pound always self-consciously used formal models to raise the ante of meaning, to borrow an occasion that could support his rhetoric--here, detached fragments of assertion are laid out like specimens under inspection. Rather than emulating classic signifiers, Watten's program appears here to consist of a debunking or parody of their permitted uses.   
  
Indeed the authorial voice seems almost to detest its ostensible subject, as if it had been imposed as an external program, hence the neutral disembodied tone, the automatized sequence of terms, the lack of a sentiment traceable back to a motive-vector. The voice seems to be saying: "My dilemma is in engaging this rehearsal of archetypes, but I am not committed to it, it is just a means to an end, an end which I am not at liberty to define, or name, at this time" (which would certainly have been an apt position to take at that point--i.e., a resistant stance). 
 
The primary nodes in the first poem--Tropicana, Wallace [Stevens], Nicaragua and Bodega Bay--provide classic nomenclature--two geographical loci, a decorative Modernist poet, and the proper name of a casino/hotel or an orange juice brand. The references are intentionally broad (vague), and undeveloped, though striking in their simplicity. Their use is completely gratuitous, inasmuch as there is no need or purpose in developing their significance or meaning in the poem. They function simply as assimilated stereotypical signs, whose associations are generic, though vivid enough, to evoke a generalized sense of familiarity without requiring greater definition, or more decisive commitment (i.e., nothing of the political or economic facts of Nicaragua need be considered, the name itself is sufficient to the case).  
  
The first poem is not a description of an equatorial state of mind, or of a specific place; it isn't an intellectual exercise about a tropical aspect, the way a poem by Hart Crane or Stevens would be. It merely uses this frame to create an artificial linguistic setting for the launching of the exercise. It's discretely insulated from any describable experience. The speaker is not placed geographically (in "Nicaragua" or Northern California ("Bodega Bay"), is not on a stage ("limelight"), is not looking at a picture in a museum ("black velvet"); it is not nighttime ("the moon"). The poem exists in a kind of limbo--neither assertive, nor reactive.      
  
It asks to be treated as a rehearsal of stereotypical platitudes ( stock images) without conviction, a renunciation of the prescriptive etymologies of performance and methodology (i.e., the work of Wallace Stevens) under which the author's official pursuit of a writerly identity, at that time, was being carried out. As previously discussed in my piece on this blog ["Lewis Turco & The Workshop System," November 11, 2008], the workshop system is a version of the institutionalized master-apprentice relationship, one in which an established canon of acceptable models of imitation and aspiration is presented as a panoply of fixed, unchallenged alternatives. The purpose of this system is the perpetuation of normative values of specimen texts, and the grooming of candidates for entry into the machinery of literary production. Potential responses to such an oppressive structure are burlesque or satire, in which codes and formulae are rejected, or mimicked as it were from the inside out, like graffiti on the bathroom wall. As forms of routine resistance or futile (political) demonstration, poems designed to martial corroboration (protest) end up being subsumed within the larger sphere of synthetic debate, leaving the self predictably thwarted.
     
This aggression--"pestering the offices of intelligence"--against authorized centres of meaning, involves not just the deconstruction of the cliches of canonical form, but a renunciation of all known profiles of (the author as) agency. To adopt any such available profiles, at that point in time, would have required a capitulation, not just to the system of judgment and coercion it represented, but an acquiescence to exhausted modes of expression. By holding the level of statement just short of assertion, limited to an objectivist nominative, it was possible to exist incognito within the sphere of textual decision, as a renegade in disguise.                               
 
The second poem adopts a quasi-scientific incremental measure, using the left-hand margin--the individual words aligned vertically along it--to count degrees of progression. Still life, as a formal cliche, is a collection of linguistic objects (or signs), which organize into distributed arrays or sets:
 
 
palm fronds -- "Nature" - a frame
 
Russian bottles -- manufactured objects 
 
my daughter [my late daughter's/pettiness] -- the social milieu 
 
winter window -- Nature through a frame
  
specie -- scientific testing and measurement -- enhanced precision 
 
edge [spectacular/ornate/immaterial/dark edge] -- sublimation of the performance --dissolution
 
 
The sequence poses an imaginary progression, parallel, but not equivalent to, the time of the poem's unfolding. The sequence of ordered objects, otherwise gratuitous and accidental, involves an increasing narrowing of focus (the conjugation of the daughter's quality, the declension of the root specie--which prefigures the expansion from material specificity towards the spectacular ornate im-materiality), beginning from generality, gradually excising, arriving at a symbolic (w)edge, which is (an) atomized "im-/material//dark edge". Spectacularity (decor) versus the immaterial (abstraction). Like the other poem, this appropriates objects as totally discrete and arbitrary things, whose referential inter-relationship is crucially, and flagrantly arbitrated, and the whole argument--if it can be called that--devolves upon a crux of dissolution, like a hammer blow on an anvil. The (w)edge's immateriality, at the molecular level, means that any edge is an illusion, any assertion provisional.               
 
This metaphorical detonation, from a Platonic materiality (ideal) to post-Modern (or post-Einsteinian) immateriality suggests the slow, inexorable explosion, popularly described as "the Big Bang." A Cartesian materiality (Watten once earnestly said to me "all thought is geometric!"), expressed through objects as ideal forms, disintegrates. The progressive advance of physics towards smaller and smaller degrees of definition of space and matter--thus triggers an objectivization, or criticism, of the signs of predestined forms, a deconstruction derived from the expansion, or the historical progression, of scientific thought. A poem which self-destructs, or de-constructs itself. Which is--to the degree of its transformation--thrown into relief by its energetic process. 
   
Whereas the first poem spins in place as a gyroscope of futility, like a planet in orbit around a futile sun--the second confronts darkness, a dying sun, entropy.
  
If an effort in these poems has been made to deconstruct a system of given signs, as a reduction of the apprentice relationship, to nonsense, nothing is offered in opposition. Beside Pound's imperative to "stand beside one's word(s)"--a contrary concept of authorial agency is posed as de-personalized intelligence. Observer and observed become one, but identity is sacrificed through this process. 
  
Language is like flypaper, seductive, sweet, sticky--but also illusive, illusory, ephemeral, flimsy, and deceptive. Try as we might to draw a line in the sand, to assign to a shifting surface a meaning with authority or permanence, it's all a terrific waste of time--or a futile (temporal) use. Along the valence of time, matter can't hold the evidence of our intentions.  
   
Walking through great piles of the county dump, of respective materials, shifting and sifted, partially sorted, rotting, rolled, humped-up into clogged and tangled banks, mirages of matter, sprinkled with acids, ammonia, perfume, vinegar, oils. The overwhelming materiality of the quotidian masquerades as random thought, but animation may simply be a projection of a mindless consumption. Why do anything? Why churn the detritus of civilization? Why not?
   
The drug lord puts out a contract on a Richmond resident, so later that night shots are heard. Behind cyclone fences, cowering misfits fry rubbery steaks. Ashen exhaust residue tinges the cinder-block. Paint drips off the ceiling. Blood circulates through the arterial tree, percolating consciousness. Turtles crossing the road crushed beneath barreling treads. Foamy Niagara sleeps through the night, churning misty nostalgias. The Chinese plate cracks, revealing weak fissures in our thought. 
   
What is the relation between present event and received wisdom, between freshly minted fear and scarred memory? An unmanned craft hovers overhead. Roaches are climbing the lampposts, looking for light. The oncoming glare of blinding brights is a sedative, numbing as the fatigue motel.                  

McGwire's Fake Contrition an Insult to Baseball

 
Mark McGwire's "confession" yesterday on television--widely reported this morning in the media--that he did indeed take "performance-enhancing" steroid drugs during his stellar pro baseball career didn't surprise anyone. The only possible surprise was that the St. Louis Cardinals, with whom he'd just signed a new contract as a team batting coach, presumably demanded that he perform this duty as a condition of being hired. Did they think it made them seem more ethically clean? That would hardly wash, since McGwire was a big-time steroids user on their watch, from 1997 through 2001. 
 
In his statement, McGwire claims that he began using steroids in the 1989-90 season, at "someone's" suggestion, to facilitate healing from his various injuries. That's a bold-faced lie. McGwire played six full seasons (1987-1992) without significant injuries. It was only in 1993, after several years of drug use, that his injuries began to pile up. He wasn't driven to use drugs by injuries, the drugs caused his injuries! 
 
Then, from 1996 through 1999, he resumed full-time play, and it was then, pumped up to unbelievable proportions by the drugs, that he built up those power numbers which are the basis of his reputation as a star player. 
 
McGwire was never a total hitter: His numbers show that he had a good eye, but he seldom hit for impressive average, or produced runs or RBI's at an impressive pace. He was big, and slow. His home runs typically were huge "pop-ups" since he seldom hit the ball squarely. His steep upper-cut swing was designed to produce those flies, and as such, an increase in his upper body strength (facilitated by the drugs) could add those extra 15-25 feet of distance that would clear most major league park fences. Many of his homers were "cheapies" landing just beyond the edge of the fence(s). 
 
This "admission" begins to look more and more like a self-serving strategy on the part of major league baseball generally. It can claim to have "cleaned up" the sport by getting McGwire, one of a handful of high profile players of whom drug use was strongly suspected, to confess publicly. But this admission is an anti-climax. Everyone knew McGwire took steroids, just as we all know Barry Bonds did.
 
The difference is that Bonds was forced to take the fall for his use, because the Federal prosecutors felt Bonds would be a good sacrificial victim. Bonds was cheeky, an "uppity" Black athlete, cocky and manipulative. If they could "get" Bonds, major league baseball could hold him up as the convicted poster boy, while the other users, like McGwire, could have their cases quietly laid to rest.  
 
McGwire was always reputedly something of a primadonna, just as Bonds has always been. But his "image" as Mr. Redheaded Nice Guy, embracing his son at home plate when he broke Ruth's record, shouldn't have fooled anyone. It's a clear instance of the discrimination which still plagues professional sports.
 
If Bonds is denied the Hall, or his stats sprout asterisks, then McGwire should share the shame. 
 
This "confession" is sheer bullshit.         

Minggu, 10 Januari 2010

Stein and A Very Nice Day


Gertrude Stein's work resists closure, resists easy analysis, resists quotation, resists description. It's slippery, and elusive. Often it seems too simple and deliberately naive. You think you have it figured out, and then you read another passage in which she throws all her (and your) assumptions about how a work proceeds out the window, and there's something ingenious and unique about it.  
 
 
 
After I took my MFA at the University of Iowa in 1972, I thought I would go on and take a Ph.D. at Berkeley. I had planned to do a thesis on Stein's work, which I thought had been neglected by the academy, and there seemed to be few people interested enough in it really to study it carefully enough to dissect and summarize its structure and signficance. Professor Richard Bridgman, at Berkeley at that time, had written a serious study, Gertrude Stein in Pieces, but when I talked with him about it, he seemed highly skeptical about the benefits of reading or studying her work; his interest in her seemed purely content-driven, as if the only point in reading an author was to discover what their private psychological obsessions might be, and how that was expressed in the work. He seemed totally uninterested in the technicalities of her writing. "She was obsessed with spiders," he told me, "among other irrational preoccupations. I can't say I'd recommend her as a subject for extended study." 
 
I ended up not resuming my academic career at that time, which was probably just as well. I don't know how it would have (re-)shaped my thinking about literature and art. The whole graduate student scene was too familiar to me, from my years of work at Iowa, and it seemed an uninspiring endeavor at that point (I was 26 at the time). The competition, the stress, the mountains of drudgery (reading). The constant arguing with professors. 
 
         
 
Reading Silliman's blog yesterday morning, in which he quotes a Stein sequence from A Long Gay Book, brought back memories of that time, when I was reading a lot of her work. Here's a selection from a series of imitations I wrote--along the lines of Jerry Rothenberg's A Stein Book [1966]--

  
There are nations, there are borders there are colors and colors are hot.
 
.
 
A rhythm, a ghost in a chance and a plaintive clopping, a snowy evening and a glass of punch, a glass of punch is a fine refresher.
 
.
 
Round ones, nice round ones dictate calm, a taste in surprises. A white surprise, a pink surprise and a color in appearing. Open and choose a custard.
 
.
 
It is essential to be a worrier, to be a worrier in need. It is essential to be a wearer of different tweed. In summer or in winter, there is need, but do not be a worrier, a worrier in winter. 
 
.
 
They have cars. They have cars and by the coast they have whistles. They know buckets and sand, they have paintings and frames and uncles. My dear rag.
 
...
 
Blotchy mountain.
We're up on
blotchy mountain.
 
.
 
How they lie in laps.
Provence.
Like they say.
These big wooden women.
 
.
 
Like a white wall.
In Portugal.
A black
and white wall in Portugal.
 
The relationship between Gertrude Stein and Ernest Hemingway is one of the most interesting in literary history. Superficially, they had little in common, but at a certain point in their lives, they became mutually fascinated and affectionate towards one another. Hemingway picked up a couple of key features of prose narrative style from her--the so-called "cubistic" strain in his writing, supposed to be derived from Juan Gris and some of Stein's short prose pieces in Geography and Plays. Their friendship was probably doomed not to last, since their life-styles were so divergent. In many of Hemingway's early stories, you can see him building up impressions and descriptions in a way that he had learned from her, often jamming many declarative phrases together in a rhythmic, propulsive recital, but measured out in rounded bars of the utmost finality and discreteness. No one had ever written prose the way Stein had discovered, and Hemingway stole that trick from her.   
 

   

Sabtu, 09 Januari 2010

What We Mean by Beat Writers - A Finite Definition

 
This is an attempt at definition. Whatever you think of the so-called Beat Writers, or the Beat Generation--their affect on American or world culture, or their literary importance--it is useful to narrow the meaning of the term 'Beat Writer' in the interests of accuracy and pertinence. 
  
The term Beat Writer has been mangled and misused and expanded to include dozens and dozens of poets and prose writers, most of whom never had any connection with the "movement" itself, and many of whom do not in any clear sense exhibit any of the aspects of Beat. Who may be considered as a true Beat?     
 
There are several problems in defining Beat. First, the term was invented before there was either a literature, or anything like a social or literary group, to which it could refer. Wikipedia states that the term Beat Generation was invented by Jack Kerouac in 1948, and that this was codified by the novelist John Clellon Holmes, in an article he published in 1952. (Holmes published a novel, Go, in 1952, about the Beat Generation, but he is only peripherally considered himself to be a Beat Writer--perhaps only a documentarian).
 
The term Beat Generation is reminiscent of the phrase The Lost Generation, coined by Gertrude Stein ["You are all a Lost Generation"] to describe those (mostly American) writers and artists who had been drawn to Europe following WWI, in the 1920's. It is not altogether clear what "Beat" was originally intended to mean, or to describe, but its associations usually include modern jazz (circa the late 1940's and 1950's), the low life associated with a rather shabby bohemianism and/or illegal drug use, lower-class disenfranchisement (dignified or voluntary poverty), and poetic inspiration ("beatific" possession, youthful romantic indulgence of a type associated with French literary figures such as Verlaine, Baudelaire, Rimbaud).            
 
In attempting to define what a Beat Writer may be, one must be careful not to assign to it specifically either a geographical or thematic element. There is no single event or group, in time, which can be used as a baseline for taxonomic inclusion. 
 
Jack Kerouac, the single most important figure in the group, grew up in Massachusetts, went to Columbia, and then dropped out. His first novel, The Town and the City, published in 1950, is in style and substance an emulation of Thomas Wolfe. His next work, On the Road, written in 1951 (originally begun in Quebecois [French dialect] and revised and expurgated before eventually being published in altered form in 1957), provides the context and tapestry of the Beat identity, and is a roman a clef--in its original form--of the semi-fictional life Kerouac imagined he was living, or would like to have lived, during those years. Kerouac traveled around a good deal during the 1950's, and met and socialized with other figures who would eventually qualify for inclusion in the movement. Several other of Kerouac's novels document his further adventures, and those of friends and acquaintances whom he had known; but On the Road is the key work in the Beat movement phenomenon.                
  
 

 
The second key figure in the Beat movement, is William S. Burroughs, an unusual and unlikely progenitor. The child of well-off Missourians, he attended Harvard (graduating in 1936), and spent most of his adult life wandering from situation to situation, experimenting with sex, crime, drugs, writing and art. He published the novel Junky, in 1953, as a dime-store dos-a-dos paperback original, a verite expose of the life of a drug addict, under the pseudonym William Lee. While living in Tangier, Morocco, 1954-58, he wrote what would, with the help of Allen Ginsberg and Kereouac, become the novel The Naked Lunch [1959]. The Naked Lunch, together with Burroughs's close ties to the key figures Ginsberg and Kerouac, place him squarely in the inner circle of the Beat movement.
 
     
 
The third crucial figure in the movement is Allen Ginsberg. Growing up in New Jersey, Ginsberg attended Columbia, and encountered Burroughs, Gregory Corso, and Lucien Carr, among others. In 1954, in the San Francisco Bay Area, Ginsberg would meet his life partner, Peter Orlovsky, compose his signature poem Howl (at the Caffe Mediterraneum in Berkeley), and read it, at the Six Gallery, in 1955. Also reading there that night were Gary Snyder, Philip Whalen, Philip Lamantia, and Michael McClure. Simply on the basis of their participation at this reading--though for other reasons, as well--all of these other four figures belong in the Beat canon. Snyder and Whalen had attended Reed College in Oregon, together, and had migrated to the Bay Area at the same time--both of them had been influenced by Kerouac, as well as by Eastern culture and Buddhism (as had Kerouac). McClure had come to San Francisco from Kansas, and after first attempting to be a painter, settled on an original poetic style whose beatific themes and content fit in well with the Beat consciousness.     
 
     
 
Lawrence Ferlinghetti arrived in San Francisco in 1953, and shortly thereafter co-founded the City Lights Bookstore and publishing venture (City Lights Books). Many of the early titles which Ferlinghetti published in his "Pocket Poets Series" would tend to be associated with the Beat movement, but only a handful actually qualify (Ginsberg, Corso, Ferlinghetti, Lamantia, Kaufman, Norse, Hirschman, Orlovsky, Kerouac); Duncan, Levertov, Patchen, Rexroth, O'Hara, etc., are not Beat writers, though books of theirs appeared in the Pocket Poets series. Hirschman, Norse, Kaufman, Lew Welch (a close associate of Snyder's), and Lamantia (a late canonical American Surrealist), Selby, Wieners, are Beats. Though peripherally associated with the Bay Area Beat figures, Meltzer, Loewinsohn, Bremser, Micheline, and Kyger are not Beats. Jack Spicer, Robert Duncan, The White Rabbit group, are not Beats.
 
Poets of The New York School (O'Hara, Berrigan, Waldman, Carroll) are not Beats. Charles Bukowski is not a Beat. D.A. Levy is not a Beat. Writers associated with Black Mountain College, The Black Mountain Review, Origin Magazine, Evergreen Magazine, Grove Press books, Olympia Press Books, etc., are not Beat by definition. J.P. Donleavy is not a Beat. Nabokov is not a Beat. Ken Kesey, despite his associations with Neal Cassidy, Allen Ginsberg and his rural Oregon background (which he shares with Snyder), and his interest in drugs and the counter-culture, is not a Beat--he belongs, with Richard Brautigan, to a later generation (perhaps the Psychedelic, or Flower Generation). 
 
The Beat movement is a phenomenon whose time-line runs from 1948 to approximately 1960. Those Beat writers included in the Allen Anthology--Corso, Ferlinghetti, Ginsberg, Kerouac, Lamantia, McClure, Orlovsky, Snyder, Welch, and Whalen--had all completed work which was clearly Beat in meaning or inspiration by that time. Adam, Broughton, Blaser, Gleason, etc., are not Beats. 
 
In limiting the definition of Beat, it's important to restrict the list to those who both produced work central to the meaning of Beat as a literary style, as well those who had clear social or professional connections to each other or to specific events. The San Francisco Renaissance, for instance, intersects or overlaps with Beat, but the two movements aren't synonymous. Claims are often made for overlap with Black Mountain, but there is no clear connection. Though Ginsberg and Burroughs and Kerouac all spent time in New York, attempts to connect them to others there during this period, don't work. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, published in 1962, is a watershed event, signaling a shift both in cultural and literary consciousness. The 1960's were in many respects a realization and flowering of the ideas and tendencies in the avant-garde of the 1940's and 1950's--and the Beats could rightfully claim that many of their inspirations, and criticisms of American life, had brought about important intellectual, political and artistic developments in that, and subsequent decades, but their period of important work was complete by 1960.

It often seems convenient, for various reasons, to imagine that the Beat movement continued through the 1960's, and even into the 1970's. Those wishing to claim an association with the Beat movement, or to co-opt later figures as continuations of Beat spirit or inspiration, usually have a poor sense of actual literary history. For instance, none of the poets included in Paul Carroll's Young American Poets anthology are Beats--because none of its contributors (except perhaps Kenward Elmslie--certainly no Beat!) had written anything before 1960. It's almost as if the concept of Beat is so pervasive, in its descriptive or adjectival sense, that it's applied without any discrimination whatsoever.
 
I often think that the true canon of Language Poetry is to be found in the early work of John Ashbery, Michael Palmer, Clark Coolidge, Larry Eigner, Jackson Mac Low and Robert Grenier, and that by the mid-1970's, that movement, such as it was, had really ended. What those in the Grand Piano project were doing, or thought they were doing, is probably "Post"-Language School work. Literary criticism and literary history usually identify what is actually happening about 10 to 20 years after the fact--sometimes even longer. What are the "canonical" works of the Language School? If you take away Ashbery's Rivers and Mountains, Tennis Court Oath and Three Poems, Palmer's Blake's Newton and Circular Gates, Coolidge's Ing, Space and The Maintains, Eigner's another time in fragments, Mac Low's Stanzas, and Grenier's Dusk Road Games, Water Farmer and A Day at the Beach, what's left?
 
It strikes me that the work that Kerouac, Burroughs, Ginsberg, Snyder, Whalen, Ferlinghetti, Corso, McClure, Lamantia and Welch all did after 1960 is interesting, fun, and different, but it does nothing to refine or modify our sense of Beat. That's because by 1960-62, what we think of as Beat had run out of steam. Each decade lays the seeds of later developments. The Sixties as a creative decade spawned the Conservative reaction of the 1980's and 1990's. What Barrett Watten refers to as "the turn to language" in the early 1970's resembles an introspection, an introversion, largely in reaction to the physicality, the indulgence and erotic sublimation of the Sixties. The reaction to that tendency, in turn, can be seen in the work and history of succeeding decades. We've just turned the corner at the end of the first decade of the 21st Century. 
  
Silliman's Alphabet has just been published. Am I living in the past, or does it seem like an anti-climax? Its first published sections are as far away from us, in time, now, as we were, in 1970, from Robert Duncan's early work (from the 1940's). Sometimes we forget how fast the ground is moving under our feet.   

Kamis, 07 Januari 2010

The Lolita-Complex in the Work of Jock Sturges


The work of Jock Sturges [1947- ] raises a number of issues which I am unable, in this short space, to address adequately. Nevertheless, he himself has proposed that his work should serve as a platform for the open discussion of nudity in photography (and in society).

For those who have not seen it, Sturges's primary emphasis is on nude pubescent or pre-pubescent girls. Due to the more permissive atmosphere regarding nudity and sex in Europe, the majority of his images have been made there.

Sturges became notorious when, in 1990, the FBI raided his photographic studio, seizing his files and images, computer, cameras. Sturges was charged with child pornography, but a San Francisco grand jury refused to indict him. Both Sturges, and British photographer David Hamilton, have come repeatedly under attack by cultural watch-dogs (like Operation Rescue, the anti-abortion group), for purportedly crossing the line from legitimate art portraiture, to child pornography.



While Sturges is a professional, in that his work is very well-done, and presented intelligently and with evident taste and care, the implications of his subject-obsession cannot be flagrantly set aside with claims of innocent regard and 1st amendment crusading. In over a dozen slick monographs and catalogues, and many exhibitions and one-man-shows, he has openly and conspicuously flaunted his preoccupation with nude young teen-aged women--easily 90% of his photographic prints are devoted to them. In addition, most of the rest of his subjects are nudes taken at different ages--children under the age of 10, or women in their twenties or thirties, with an occasional young nude male in the mix. In short, Sturges has emphasized his obsession with pre-pubescent young nude women, almost to the exclusion of any other type of subject-matter, even though he is known to have done much other commercial (non-art, non-nude) work, such as of ballet.

Clearly, Sturges wishes to make a point, and he is unashamed and earnest about it. Let's think a bit about what he might be trying to tell us.



Traditionally, the nude as subject in art has been a hot topic. Prior to the 20th Century, images of nude children were almost absent from art generally, though tactfully posed, and modestly conceived images of children and adolescents were common in ancient sculpture and reliefs, and in Renaissance and post-Renaissance painting and sculpture. In late 19th Century England, Lewis Carroll (Charles Dodgson), took a number of pictures of young girls, which some critics believe border on a prurient regard for "little girls"--no surprise, perhaps, given that Carroll's signature work, Alice in Wonderland [1865], features a pre-pubescent English girl. Missing portions of Dodgson's Diaries, and certain facts about his life, tend to suggest that he may have been a paedophile; indeed, Dodgson may have intended to propose marriage to 11-year old Alice Liddell, the presumed model for the fictional Alice.

In the 20th Century, Vladimir Nabokov's Lolita [Paris: Olympia Press, 1955], provided a striking instance of a fictionalized paedophilic narrator, Humbert Humbert--whose fixation upon, and adventures with, a New England high school ingenue constituted a fully fleshed-out, and evidently unashamed portrayal of a psychological type which has come to be associated with her name. Though clearly not in the clinical sense a paedophile himself, Nabokov the Author sought to realize a version of the type in no uncertain terms.

I am not trained in psychology, and indeed I'm not altogether invested in psychology as a scientific discipline, believing (as I do) that the field is still in its relative infancy, and that what we don't know about human thought and feeling is of a very much greater portion than that which we do know. However, it is believed by some theorists that genuine paedophiles experience an arrested personality, causing them to fixate on pre-adult girls, instead of adult women. Why and how this occurs, is a matter of dispute among psychologists and psychiatrists. But it seems to be associated with otherwise introverted personalities, whose sense of guilt or rejection reinforces and rationalizes their obsession. There are even some, referred to by supporters as the childlove movement, who advocate the relaxation of age-of-consent laws and mental illness classifications (as child molestation).



It's often convenient to imagine that the time-line of civilized practice is quite long, but we know without any doubt that what we think of as settled society and culture is a very late (new) human development. Our ancestors didn't begin living in "permanent" communities until very late in the game. Life expectancy in pre-civilized circumstances (tribal and/or nomadic), which went on for hundreds of thousands of years, was short, perhaps 30-35 years. It is generally assumed that sexual activity began much earlier in "pre-civilized" human society than it commonly does these days. Girls reaching puberty at age 12-14 began to bear children immediately, experiencing multiple pregnancies, accompanied by many lost infants, by their mid-twenties. What this means in real terms, is that what we now tend to regard with surprise and perhaps revulsion, was probably the behavioral norm among primitive human societies. The idea of regardng very young girls as potential sex objects, desirable and ripe for indoctrination and mating, is a much older and more common "tradition" than the customs, laws and habits which have developed over the last 4000 years. Age-of-consent debates, and various controversial religious precepts regarding procreation notwithstanding, cultural notions of prescribed social and sexual interaction between individuals have undergone changes over time, and there are significant differences among present-day cultures--primitive, residual and "modern"--which suggests that there is no hard and fast definition across the spectrum of human society that supports a single interpretation of the meaning and variation of sexual imagery.

Is Sturges's work an example of unsublimated sexual obsession, masquerading as a system of valorization of his subjects' confident identity and lack of shame, as he has claimed in his public statements? What exactly do Sturges's images of naked girls, standing idly on beaches or by bungalows, or in forest settings, tell us about them, or him?

Traditionally, sexually charged images may resemble multiple different idealizations. When people refer to "child pornography" today, they usually mean the unwanted exploitation of innocent (i.e., "underage") subjects, designed and made to appeal to those for whom such images are a form of vicarious stimulation and prurient regard--a projection of forbidden indulgence, a secret game or pastime. Sturges has said that his images "respect" the subjects' lives and personalities, that they "own" their bodies in a way which is neither prurient, nor naively beguiled.

But how subjects may feel about themselves, or about what images of them may actually mean, either in terms of the range of cultural contexts in which they are viewed, or how the full implication or eventual consequences may not be clear to them, is not a separate, irrelevant fact about this process. This is especially true of innocent subjects, who may not yet fully realize the degree of appropriation of their identities and lives which photographic reproduction may entail. Are girls of 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15 or 16 years of age, fully capable of taking full responsibility for the potential consequences of becoming nude subjects, published or displayed around the world? Does the model release, or even parental consent, entitle an artist (or photographer) to seize the souls of children, to capture their identities for purposes which go far beyond some admittedly immature sense of permission which they may imagine they are feeling?

In what sense, ultimately, are we obliged to accept the pretext of Sturges's claim of politically correct "beauty" or "innocence" or morally neutral aesthetic exploration, in place of the more damning assessment of a "perverted" obsession to expose pre-pubescent girls to a serious art public?

The unadorned human body, in all its various manifestations, is subject to as many different feelings and meanings as there are kinds of people. In the totally objective sense, a naked human body is neither more, nor less, the sum of its purposes and functions. Its structure is determined by genetic inheritance, and subject to the manipulations, augmentations and transformations of aging, defacement, or decoration. It means what we want it to mean. In the hands of a photographer, a photograph tends to mean what the photographer wants it to mean: He intends that this image be seen in this way, for this purpose. On balance, I'd have to say that Sturges wants us to see and appreciate pre-pubescent or early pubescent girls as desirable, beautiful, unspoiled, and ultimately, as common things, i.e., the more we see of them, the less shocking and unusual they will seem. Is this an exploitation, or a de-sensitization, of innocence? Probably both. No matter how hard Sturges may try, he can't altogether succeed in making us believe that an 11-year old fully comprehends the meaning of her nakedness before his vision.

In Lolita, Nabokov suggested, indirectly, that Humbert Humbert, rather than being the seducer, the manipulator, was indeed the victim, not just of his own obsession, but of the shrewd manipulations of his love-object. Despite her supposed innocence and guilelessness, she used Humbert to attain her selfish ends. But that was fiction. Sturges is photographing real girls, who live real lives. Sturges may fantasize, or not, about his subjects, in ways that belie his vaunted artistic program. But no one who so single-mindedly, and determinedly, labored so hard to expose a forbidden subject as Sturges has done, can claim not to have some very powerful personal (and ulterior) motives. The sense of violation and discomfort which accompanies a viewing of his images doesn't go away.

[Note: I have posted three of Sturges's images, commonly available for download on the internet. I could have made copies of these same, or other, images from several of his books. I chose these because they were among the most "tame" in terms of exposure. I do not wish to offend anyone, or to incite morbid curiosity. They are for illustration only.]