Selasa, 05 Januari 2010

Boss It's the Plane! The Plane! (William Garnett the aerial magician)



William Garnett [1916-2006] was that most unusual modern hybrid, the aerial art image photographer. Aerial photography has a long distinguished history as a form of documentation--geographical, military, agricultural, mapping, astronomical--but seldom did people imagine that images of the planet, seen from a considerable height--mostly possible only from airplanes--could be artistic. Flying home from service in the military, Garnett sat in the cock-pit with the pilot, and was amazed at what he was seeing, and decided right then and there to explore the possibilities of aerial image-making. The rest, as they say, is history.          
 
Almost alone in a very uncrowded field, beginning in the 1950's, Garnett began to build up a portfolio of mostly black and white images, taken by him on solo flights in his shiny silver Cessna. He moved to Napa in 1958--ironic from my perspective, since that was where I grew up (from 1954 to 1968, when I removed to Berkeley to attend UC as an undergraduate)--earning money as a police photographer, of all things, in addition to other commercial work, eventually joining the College of Environmental Design in Berkeley in 1968.  
 
 

I think I first saw Garnett's work at the Vision Gallery in San Francisco in the late 1980's. In any case, I was so impressed by it at that point, that I invested in one of his original dunes prints (the 7th image going down in sequence here). Garnett, almost alone in his field, had long been recognized, though the general public wasn't aware of his work until the 1990's, when the UC Press published the book pictured below (William Garnett Aerial Photographs, Berkeley: [University of California Press, 1994]). Earlier, he'd published a collection of color images, The Extraordinary Landscape [Boston: Little, Brown, 1982], but those images were poorly reproduced, and the color reproduction technology employed gave little sense of the astounding precision and vision of his black and white work. Nathaniel Owings of SOM introduced his work in a book The American Aesthetic [New York: Harper & Row, 1969], but this seemed more like an idea book than a book focused on the images themselves. Wider appreciation had to await the UC Press book, published in Garnett's 78th year! Here, for the first time, a cross-section of his images showed how revolutionary and impressive his oeuvre had become.  
        
Images of earth's surface provide a varied visual palette of textures, many highly abstract and formally weird. How astounded I was to learn that he'd made most of these images with 35 millimeter, or medium format cameras! Typically, Garnett would print these images at very large scale, 24x36 or larger. The incredible detail he was able to capture suggested enormous lenses, or high resolution flat plane lens acuity. But apparently not. 
   

According to Garnett's account, he would discover a subject that appealed to him, set the plane on a circular path, lock the controls, and then lean out through the cockpit window with his camera, on the plane's tilt! For those of us who bitch about the inconveniences and hazards of large format photography, this strenuous and improbable technique is a cautionary reminder. 
   
 
Often, on transcontinental jet flights, I've marveled at the extraordinary land forms of the American southwest--the stark plains, jagged mesas, sandpapery scrub, folded and plaited dunes, etc. But Garnett's aerial work typically was done at far lower altitudes than jet passenger vehicles fly. Ansel Adams constructed a special "camera car" for himself, in which the top of the vehicle was equipped with a plywood platform, which enabled him  to photograph from a point high enough off the ground, to avoid fronting foliage and clutter. But the secret fantasy of many landscape photographers has always been the potential viewpoint somewhere between being stuck on the ground, and being trapped inside a moving airplane. Video work from helicopters and small single-man craft is just beginning to be explored these days. Who knows how much more sophisticated we'll become in the years ahead, at enabling low level access to landscape views?
 
             

Garnett's studies frequently suggest a level of abstraction that bids fair for comparison with the most interesting of the Abstract Expressionists or post-Expressionist painters. Along with other land-based photographers like Brett Weston, his work suggests that imagined landscapes are no more interesting than the real world ("Reality is greater than our dreams"--Frederick Sommer). The problem here is that it's impossible to perceive the quality of detail in these images, unless one can view them at scale (in wall-sized prints). The images I've chosen here--mostly for their variety and range--can't be fully appreciated in these tiny photoshop versions. But it is possible to get a sense of their variation. 
 
  

One peculiar effect is of scale. Occasionally, the images seem so unreal that it's hard imagine quite what one is looking at, or at what distance the image is seen. What's impressive is frequently the persistent regularity of lines, on the one hand, contrasted with the seductive irregularity of natural forms on the other. One thing I seem obsessively to do while driving long distances, is looking at precisely planted rows of trees or crops in agricultural landscapes, watching the coordinates line up, and re-align at strict intervals--the grid points shifting as one moves around or along the periphery. Something like this pleasure takes place in Garnett's images of planted fields.  
  
 
                                                  Death Valley Dunes


Frequently, the images suggest symbolic objects: Nudes, striated glass, floured dough, veins, tree or plant networks, liquid waves, cloth, etc. This suggestibility is precisely what Garnett is after, one imagines. The metaphorical suggestiveness of abstraction is one aspect of what drives our interest and curiosity in it. In painting, lyrical abstraction was considered a liberation from the symbolism of gratuitous pictorial reference(s), and photography joined the party beginning in the 1960's. Today, such kinds of distortion and "elegant gorp" (Brett Weston) are treated as fully entitled endeavors, from images blurred into unrecognizability, to lurid color reversals, collaged multiple exposures, and manipulations of all kinds--though tending away from the clear, vivid image focus which first drove photographic innovation in the 1930's and 1940's (i.e., the f64 Group). 

Garnett may be seen as belonging squarely in the clear focus tradition, with the additional emphasis on earthscapes as abstract maps of structure, geologic forces, large scale sculptural alterations. And Garnett is not alone in this area: Think of Smithson's ambitious landscape excavations, Gohlke's aerial work at Mt. St. Helens, Gowin's studies of industrial and extraction sites, Burtynski's eerie surreal color studies of forms on the land.       
 
      

Garnett prefigures all these variant branches of man's larger awareness via our bird's-eye vantage, seeing not just visual inspiration but, ironically, a growing awareness of what our presence on the planet is actually doing. The first great psychological illumination to come from man's trip to the moon was the photographs of earth taken from far out in space. People were astonished at how self-contained, small, and fragile our small planet was! Aerial photography provides us with glimpses of truth, furnishing cautionary images of how complacent man has been in his exploitation and appropriation of the environment. 
   
  

Man's footprint is large, and destructive, but his evident power over nature also may give us hope. Rather than being merely slaves or victims of accident and rapid change, we have the ability to augment and redeem. Nearly all of nature now is subject to man's whims, to his willful desires and ambitions. Animals are becoming extinct; raw materials are being used up; the soil, the water and the air are all being consumed and expended for our convenience.

    

How long can this rapid expansion into the environment, the wholesale chewing up and spitting out of our material inheritance, go on without devastating consequences?

   

Thanks to artists like Garnett, we are able to see both the beauty of our landscape--and in a new way--and perceive how delicate and vulnerable it is. Land--landscape--doesn't exist merely to be used, as if it existed only as some kind of limitless "resource" for human manipulation; it existed long before we arrived, and doubtless will continue long after we've become extinct.

The photographs taken by the Mars Rover Mission vehicle, of limitless expanses of orange-red sand, lifeless, without movement, without agency, without purpose, are a grim confirmation that we're only one remote outpost of animated consciousness in the universe. It's unlikely that humankind will ever be less lonely than we are now.  

Minggu, 03 Januari 2010

The Tarbaby & The Gullible Clown



The incident involving an attempted terrorist bombing of a Northwest Airlines passenger jet arriving in Chicago from Holland on Christmas Day, has focused world attention on the nation of Yemen, where the Nigerian terrorist suspect was allegedly trained by Al Quaeda operatives on suicide bomb techniques. President Obama and others in his administration have acknowledged that the U.S. has been funding anti-terrorist efforts in concert with the Yemeni government, and that Yemen is known to harbor a virulent Al Quaeda presence, proselytizing and training potential terrorist operatives. There was talk this weekend on the news-talk programs of possible American military involvement in Yemen.        
 
 

One of the main pretexts for invading Iraq originally was the (fake) suspicion by our foreign intelligence agencies that Iraq harbored Al Quaeda cells, and that that nation posed a de-facto threat to American security, in addition to which it was attempting to develop a military nuclear threat by refining uranium and acquiring missile delivery capability.
 
As everyone by now knows, Iraq was not developing nuclear weapons, and had no rocket technology with which to deply such weapons, even if they had had them. 
 
In other words, the Bush Administration coerced the American intelligence community, and duped our allies (and the American Congress and the American people) into supporting a pre-emptive invasion of Iraq. The invasion, and subsequent internecine political complications there, in the years since, have done nothing to safeguard the American population, and have in fact provided the Islamic terrorist factions with new propaganda ammunition in the court of public opinion. 
 
After initially subduing the broad countryside in Afghanistan, America was unable either to capture bin-Laden, or to insure the democratization of that country, where age-old, internal, ethnic and religious factions have proven to be more resistant to cooperation or national consolidating priorities than ever before. Indeed, our actions in Afghanistan have caused neighboring Pakistan to become destabilized, to the extent that some experts in the field now expect Pakistan to fall eventually under Taliban rule within the next decade--despite huge infusions of American aid and diplomatic pressure.  
 
In short, the money and lives we've spend in Iraq and Afghanistan have yielded almost nothing in terms of improved relations, or any significant ground gained in the shadow war with Islamic terrorism. And now there are those who are advocating that the U.S. engage Islamic terrorist factions in Yemen.             
 
 

Yemen is, like Iraq, the creation of European colonial powers. It's a marginal country, with a large sprawling peasant population living in hopeless poverty. Unlike Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Iraq, and Iran Yemen has few oil reserves--and these are expected to be played out very soon. It's heavily Islamic, and is thus--along with its poverty--a fertile breeding ground for terrorist inflluence. 
 
    
 
If our adventures in Iraq and Afghanistan have taught us anything, it's that Al Quaeda isn't geographically limited to a single nation. In fact, most of the leaders of the Islamic terrorist movement are Saudis or Egyptians. The terrorist network is now being described as "horizontal"--which is to say it is not linked to any specific national or geographic region, but operates across boundaries, using the modern technologies of computers, cell-phones, and suicide volunteers. In other words, it doesn't make sense for U.S. planners to imagine that we can defeat it by engaging indigenous populations or "host" nations. We could "level" the mountainous regions of Northeastern Afghanistan and Northwest Pakistan, and we'd be no closer to stamping out Al Quaeda than before.  
 
Nevertheless, the illusion persists in our public discussions in America, that this is a "war" which can be "won" in the conventional way, by subduing foreign nations, and by making them "safe" for democratic conversion ("nation building").
 
This is simply folly. We are not going to succeed in building a democratic nation in any of the Near, or Middle Eastern nations. Islam, and the conditions on the ground, preclude anything like that. 
 
It's also clear that one of Al Quaeda's original intentions was to cause the Western powers to engage in futile military adventures, draining their resources, and stirring up unrest and indignation amongst indigenous Arab, Afghan and other native populations. We have fallen right into this trap. With relatively little expenditure either of funds or of human capital, the terrorists have been able to coerce us into futile conflicts. 
 
Meanwhile, China and India are seeing double-digit economic growth year upon year, and now are bidding to surpass the U.S. in exports, GNP, and net wealth. 
 
In effect, Al Quaeda has managed, with the most modest of means, to tip the balance of world power against The West. Who could have predicted that this would happen, even 10 years ago?       

More Howlers from the Crumbling Media




Here's a new list of additions to the hall of infamy in the castle of bad grammar. 
 
"...had they of been able to...[or]...if they'd of..."
 
Again, the confusion between use of the participle had with the preposition of. Have had thus becomes had of--which is meaningless. Drop the of and simply say "had they been able to" or "if they had."    
 
"...the good thing is, is that it is what it is..."
 
The redundancy of is/is here, sounds obvious, but I actually heard a television newscaster use this phrase in a sentence. This tautology of "it is what it is" explains nothing, and seems a poor way to summarize the self-evidency of any assertion or principle.        
  
"...as best as I can..."
 
In comparisons, you can't use a superlative in degrees of difference. The principle becomes obvious if you try to subsitute another superlative in place of best. Like, for instance, as funniest as, or as prettiest as, or as stupidest as. As best as isn't English. Don't use it!
  
"...a mute point..."
 
Misuse of the word moot. This mistaken mispronunciation tends to suggest that the speaker doesn't know the real definition of either word--mute or moot. 
  
"...it's just simplier..."
 
One television newscaster let this one slip by in a rush. She meant "more simply" or "easier" and somehow confused the two constructions.   
  
"...for my breakfastses..."
 
For a while, I thought that maybe I was just hearing people pronounce breakfasts wrongly, but I realize now that some people seem to think the plural of breakfast is breakfasts-es. Really uneducated people pronounce breakfast "breakfus" (as if it had no "t"), and then call plural breakfasts "breakfusses". Sounds loony, yes?   

Sabtu, 02 Januari 2010

A ' Jar


       
Anecdote of the Jar 
 
I placed a jar in Tennessee, 
And round it was, upon a hill. 
It made the slovenly wilderness 
Surround that hill.
 
The wilderness rose up to it, 
And sprawled around, no longer wild. 
The jar was round upon the ground 
And tall and of a port in air.
 
It took dominion every where. 
The jar was gray and bare. 
It did not give of bird or bush, 
Like nothing else in Tennessee.
 
 
This poem by Wallace Stevens has always intrigued me. It's one of his most popular, most quoted, and most discussed poems as well. It's in dozens of high school and college literature anthologies, because of its apparent simplicity, its efficient brevity of assertion.  To begin with, it isn't merely the record of a thing simply found, but an object which the speaker, the poet, has placed into an environment. Every landscape in the history of poetry is--at least to some degree--the classical landscape of the garden, not just any garden, but a man-made garden, and even the original Garden of Eden. 
 
What is so intriguing about this very simple, and seemingly unambitious poem?
 
Well, to begin with, Stevens was a New Englander, who very much enjoyed visiting Florida. Stevens's poetry is filled with a lushness, an ornateness of phrase and image which is like the imaginative plumage of some exotic species of epicurean dandy. Much of his meditative verse is occupied with the opposition between intellectual refinement and sensual indulgence. Nature is a beautiful, but untamed, context, within which the mind--assaulted by sensation, virtually drunk on sights, smells, touches, colors, sounds, sensory perturbations of various kinds--twists and stretches, moans and hums with pleasure, delight, revulsion, in a sort of grand inebriation.
 
But Stevens was a businessman, an executive in a large insurance company, and he had a duty and a role to play in the world. He was no bohemian in his outward existence, so his poetry--and his thinking about art--got compartmentalized into the larger respectable identity he created for himself and his family. Rather like Charles Ives--another cultured New Englander--Stevens harbored a dazzling creative imagination behind his dour upper-middle class exterior. That "slovenly wilderness" is classic Stevens. Who would call the wilderness "slovenly" except a lapsed moralist, who saw in Nature (with a capital N) the wild, untamed, dangerous, seductive sensuality of sin! Or, at least, in aesthetic terms, a place of disorganization, chaos, disorder, confusion, unformed or undisciplined by the hand of man or god. (Science, of course, reveals to us more and more, as time goes by, the inherent, implacable and ruthless efficient order of nature, rather than its randomness, its accidental dissimilarities and inequities. And Stevens is very much concerned with weighing and testing these dichotomies.) 
 
The poem sets up the classical Metaphysical dichotomy between Nature and Man-made Form, and asks us to imagine what the effect the existence of a man-made object might imply within the context of a "wild" landscape. The jar "civilizes" the nature in which it rests. Simply by existing, by maintaining its structural integrity, the jar influences the rest of the universe. The existence of a single created, molded, formed object (which didn't exist before it was made) affects the totality of structure, the philosophical vacuum of the universe--the "natural" non-human set of laws and material of which the "universe" is composed. So the poem is a philosophical proposition in which the introduction of a plain, aesthetically neutral object--"gray and bare"--whose roundness, plain formality of shape, which derives from nothing "in" nature--"giving nothing of bird or bush"--establishes an aesthetic-ethical superiority--a "dominion" taken from nature, separate from it, superior to it, and resistant to incorporation, inclusion, decay, and wildness. Not the physical jar--which, in due course, will crumble and disappear as form--but the idea, the blueprint of its form, the hand of the maker, the mind of the creator. 
 
This notion of an aesthetic purity, an inviolable ideal formality was very much on my mind in my early days as a writer. An early poem of mine from the 1970's, here, sets out an idealized formality which I quite liked at the time:

                     Descartes

The tulips are sublime mechanisms
Pink and yellow wafers on hinges--
 
Nothing that can be thought
Matches the simplicity of their essences
 
Which reproduce themselves
With the subtlest variations
  
Upon an ideal conception
That does not exist
  
Except in
Bluprint.            
 
 
Descartes is considered the "Father of Geometry" (a subject in which I excelled, at least until things got too complex in first year Calculus), and famously coined the phrase "I think; therefore I am." The "Cartesian" notion of an idealized universal structural paradigm has had untold influence on the course of philosophical thinking over the three and a half centuries since Descartes' time, and is still attractive. The implication of his line of thinking, that self-consciousness--accurately described and reflexively confirming--can comprehend the universe, is in large part responsible for freeing human thought from much superstition, and liberating scientific inquiry from confining religious doctrine(s). 
 
This kind of rationalism is very tempting, but it has been brought into serious question by post-Einsteinian physics and cosmology. 
 
So my attempt in the poem was to caricature Cartesian rationality whilst making a beautiful object, whose fragility and uncertain fixity were merely passing indulgences. "Blueprint" was both the colorful "beautiful" object and the metaphor for the rational "plan" from which all living things (or all corporeal existence) derive. A-"religious", but not denying the possibility of an intelligent design, i.e., the poet's!    

Jumat, 01 Januari 2010

Jan Karski - WWII Polish Freedom Fighter & Witness to the Holocaust



Over the last few weeks, I've been intermittently reading a book called Story of a Secret State [Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1944] , by Jan Karski, which I've just finished. Karski * was a Polish diplomat at the beginning of the war with Germany on September 1st, 1939, who ended up working for the duration of the conflict with the Polish Underground Resistance, which period this book describes in some detail. Karski's harrowing tale, filled with narrow escapes, imprisonment and torture by the Gestapo, and fascinating glimpses into wartime Poland, concludes with an account of his attempts, upon reaching the West, to make known the facts of the German concentration and death camps, and the ongoing Holocaust. 
 
     
  
Last year, I read Nicolson Baker's book Human Smoke ** [New York: Simon & Schuster, 2008], which is devoted to some degree in providing a sort of documentary history of the progress of the Holocaust, and the reaction and attitude towards it by the leaders of the "West." I was probably not surprised to learn how callous Churchill and Roosevelt and other figures were towards the early rumors, and later confirmations, of hardships and atrocities suffered by the Jews, ethnic minorities, and the disabled, but I was astonished at the failure of historians to tell this story before now.
    
 

Karski managed to escape to the West in 1943, by way of Berlin, Paris, Southern France, Barcelona, Algeciras, Gibralter, thence first to London, and eventually Washington DC. The story he would tell constituted one of the first unimpeachable confirmations of the continuing "Final Solution" of the Nazis--the Holocaust. And yet, few in the West were willing either to publicly acknowledge the atrocities, or to take any action to alleviate the fate of European Jews and "Undesirables"--a fact that continues to weigh on the conscience of the world, now, 70 years later.
   
Initially captured by the Russians--who, if your history is a little fuzzy here--invaded Poland from the East as the Germans invaded from the West--Karski managed to escape and join the Polish Underground, a vast shadow network of administration, government-in-hiding and -in-exile. Eventually captured by the Gestapo, he endured unspeakable torture, which led him to attempt suicide by slitting his wrists--leading to another supreme irony, as the hospitalization for this self-inflicted injury eventually facilitated his escape, and the resumption of his primary function as courier for the Underground.
  
Despite severe poor health, malnourishment, and the oppressive facts of Poland's defeat, demoralization and economic exploitation by their occupiers, Karski survived trial after trial, escape after narrow escape, to survive and bear witness to the events of Nazi tyranny. Before departing for the West, he was taken secretly to visit the Warsaw Ghetto, and also one of the staging transfer camps set up to relocate the Jewish population on its way to the death camps. Karski did not witness the actual death camps, believing that the prisoners were allowed to "die" on trains, before being buried in unmarked graves in the countryside. Had he understood how organized and ruthless the extermination process had become, how much more convincing or compelling would his accounts have been, when he was finally allowed, in company with the Polish Ambassador to Washington, to meet with Roosevelt, and describe the things he had seen? 
  
After the War, unable to return to his native Poland, Karski took a Ph.D. at Georgetown University, and spent the rest of his 40 year work life as a professor in East European International Affairs. Polish freedom fighters had originally believed that after the War, Poland could be reconstituted as a democracy, but the Soviet occupation during the decades of the Cold War dashed those hopes. Karski became an American citizen in 1954, and for a time his efforts on behalf of Polish (and European) Jewry were forgotten. After the fall of communism in Poland in 1989, Karski's wartime role was officially acknowledged there for the first time, and he was honored (decorated) there, as well as being made an honorary citizen of the State of Israel, a tree being planted bearing his name at the Yad Vashem's Valley of the Righteous Among the Nations. 
  
Karski's witness stands as a repudiation of the Western powers during the War years: "It was easy for the Nazis to kill Jews...the allies considered it impossible and too costly to rescue [them]...The Jews were abandoned by all governments, church hierarchies and societies, but thousands of Jews survived because of...individuals in Poland, France, Belgium, Denmark, Holland who helped to save [them]...Now, every government and church says 'We tried to help the Jews,' because they are ashamed, they want to keep their reputations...They didn't help, [and those] six million Jews perished...but those in government, in the churches, they survived...No one did enough." [his words]
 
A statue of Karski commemorates his deeds and teaching career on the Georgetown Campus.                            
 
*Wikipedia Entry on Karski.
**New York Times Review of Baker's Human Smoke.

Rabu, 23 Desember 2009

The Lounge Lizard - Sophisticated New Drink






The Lounge Lizard is an old term for an habitue of cocktail lounges, an idle man who haunts establishments frequented by the rich or fashionable. Not an endearing term, to say the least. 
  
The apogee of the cocktail was in the Nineteen Twenties, when the high life was in vogue. Drinking cocktails was a mark of leisured luxury. Maybe in those days, the idea of spending time in a cocktail lounge wasn't frowned upon. It seems like something invented, maybe, in the 1940's or '50's, during the gritty noir, progressive jazz era, when soulful self-destructive hypnotic degradation was deemed "cool."
  
In any case, here's my latest creation, dubbed The Lounge Lizard--a sophisticated, elegant drink poised between sweet and dry, smooth and edgy.     
  
Recipe:
  
2 parts straight rye
2 parts Drambuie
1 part Southern Comfort
1.5 parts fresh lime juice
  
shaken hard and served up
  
By the way, for those who don't know, the only way to serve cocktails is as cold as possible. The glass should be kept in the freezer compartment for at least 5 minutes before filling, and the drink should be shaken hard for at least 50 strokes before pouring. Ideally, there should be tiny fragments of ice in the drink, to enhance its bracing, frosty character. Anytime you order a drink at a tavern, and they send it out luke-warm or room-temperature, it's almost certainly a mistake. Make'em re-do it!  

Minggu, 20 Desember 2009

Minimalism Part VI: Creeley's Collected Later Poems - Little'uns


From the time Creeley initiated his mimimalist phase, in the third section of Words [1967], he explored the possibilities of a poetry based on the smallest, meticulously conceived formulae--or just a handful of carefully placed words--like ingeniously arranged integers, pieces, ciphers, etc.--until the late 1970's, when he resumed the more traditional, characteristic formalities of his earlier career in the volume Hello [1976], which came out amongst a flurry of prose publications including the diary section of A Day Book [1972], Contexts [1973], Mabel [1977], Presences [1976], Was That a Real Poem [1979]. It seemed as if this winnowing, or applied concisions, in Pieces [1969] had forced a reassessment of capability, under the pressure of an interest that had either gone dry, or had reached a logical conclusion in Thirty Things [1974] (about which I have written earlier--see below).
 
       

Creeley never wholly abandoned the form, though he did tend to write in more "relaxed" terms for the remainder of his life. Some kind of emotional consolidation or retrospective mood seems to have overtaken him in late middle age.
  
Still, there are fascinating examples of the "Pieces" style, even into the new century. Here are several examples of his later mimimalist style from Windows [1990], published 20 years after Pieces.
 
  
 
Curious
key hole.
 
.
 
NEGATIVE
There's a big
hole.
 
.
 
FIELDS
Meadows
more at home.
 
.
 
THE KIDS
Little
muffins
 
in a
pan.
 
.
 
That ice
cream cone'll
 
drip?
 
. 
 
I got something stuck
in my hand.
 
It was a splinter.
 
.
 
TEACHER
The big
red
apple. 
 
 
Examples like these show a more relaxed motive than the poems in Pieces, which seemed very much like ulterior speculations about cognition, big resolutions, as if the emotional overkill of the poems from the Fifties and early Sixties had been boiled down to some granular density beyond which no further reduction or elaboration might be possible. But these poems seem more playful, even when they're not particularly cheerful in their implication(s)--like toys one might put on a table for a child to play with. Their irreducibility seems a consequence of simplicity, rather than conviction. "The big/red/apple" has a cartoon-like naivete, in which the voice seems overwhelmed by the pretense of pedagogy (TEACHER), and responds with blunt humor. The capital letters function thus as glowering symbolic emblems of fear, intimidation, or power--characteristically seen from a subservient or infantile position: A terrible giant baby!--almost like one of those block-headed Marisol babies. 
  
 
That ice
cream cone'll
 
 
--the concatenation of hard K sounds--cream/cone'll--enjambed against the elided cone will suggesting the double L's surfeit will topple off, like melting cream off the edge of the stanza, landing on/in the space [occupied by] the word "drip". The moral imprecation--a warning of possible disaster(s)--is resolved/realized in the embarrassment of the word ("drip") itself, the sticky accident of guilt. In William Carlos Williams, such an ingenious little engine would describe a phenomena, without implying any ironic separation--discrete positioning and simple objectification. But the authorial voice in Creeley's poems explores the means--and the implications of those means--deconstructing the effects and laying bear their disguised emotional spins, their terrors and fears.                
  
This sensitivity to individual letters, evokes kinetic qualities at the smallest possible level of our apprehension of words (or speech sounds--phonemes). It may be that certain speakers--more sensitive to the clues of language--comprehend it at the level of decomposition, or phonemal fragmentation. Certain combinations of words elicit senses of sound or meaning which are otherwise hidden inside the habitual orders of syntax or speech. These "loops" as Creeley sometimes referred to them--which suggests both little parabolic spins and nooses--are like kernals of insight or fascination. We may not at first understand how or why they are so effecting, and indeed they may remain invisible to the casual reader who only comprehends at the quotidian level of syntactical meaning. But poetry at its best is very much concerned with the slants, rings, catches, undulations and tics of common interchange, embedded in the matrix of general discourse.
 
 
FIELDS
Meadows
more at home.
 
 
--may function as a code: fields/meadows/more//at home sings as one half of a traditional nursery rhyme.   
 
 
1 / 2-3 / 4 / 5-6  
 
 
which would be followed by
 
 
7 / 8 / 9-10
 
[as in full fathom five or some similar echoing refrain]
 
 
With at home suggesting a domestication in nature as opposed to the misappropriation of land for cultivation, so that "at home" attached to more "domesticates" meadows, links the pastoral to the poetic. If the speaker could be said to be advocating meadows over fields, then FIELDS--as in the earlier poem TEACHERS--functions in a similarly oppressive way, as if in opposition. Thus individual words are treated in opposition to each other--tiny triads--having attractions and resistances deliberately contained in the setting of the poem. Words as things, or as waves of connotation that oscillate in different frequencies in different specific contexts. This dialectical places the poet in an ambiguous relationship to "subject matter"--where words are not simply tools for expression, implying an alienation from language. Doubt and suspicion and skeptical regard are the hallmarks of such a practice, both excusing the speaker from the persuasive associations of syntax and signification, and freeing up our apprehension of the process of composition.   
 
These senses are endlessly fascinating, though Creeley's need to "say something" appears to have expanded over time, such that the syntactical burden needed to carry his "message" expanded with it. It may be that he tended eventually to regard (his) minimalist works with a skeptical suspicion, deeming them "innocent" explorations, the effects of which were too difficult to adequately control the purposes to which he might put his ulterior summations, about life and writing, the social, relational, aspects of his accrued experience, in later age. If we're to regard this as an aberration of his development as a poet, or as a predictable consequence of a long life's total commitment to an evolving view of the potentials of artistic endeavor, we'd best acknowledge the value of the work itself, instead of what it may signify about the meaning of his biography.   
 
 
INSIDE MY HEAD
  
Inside my head a common room,
a common place, a common tune,
a common wealth, a common doom
  
inside my head. I close my eyes.
The horses run. Vast are the skies,
and blue my passing thoughts' surprise
  
inside my head. What is this space
here found to be, what is this place
if only me? Inside my head, whose face?
 
 
[from Life and Death, New Directions, 1994]