Kamis, 10 Desember 2009

My E.B. White



 
I can't remember exactly when I first became aware of E.B. White. My Mom had been an admirer of The New Yorker since her youth (she grew up in Neena, Wisconsin in the 1930's), and all the magazine's original big name columnists and journalists were familiar names to her. For my 18th birthday, she gave me a subscription as a Christmas present. The first issue I received contained John McPhee's Profile of Bill Bradley, then a star basketball player at Princeton University, and later a Rhodes Scholar, and so on. In any case, working at the Napa City-County Public Library during my Junior and Senior years of high school, I routinely shelved books by White, and at some point--probably in my Junior year--I'd picked up a copy of The New Yorker at the local pharmacy store magazine rack, and was intrigued by its format. There was no table of contents, and much of its front matter consisted of extremely detailed accounts of happenings, events and goings-on in New York City. There were very sophisticated cartoons and strange little quotations at the tail end of longer articles (which were called "news breaks"). I'm not sure what I made of it at the time, but as I say, it was intriguing.  
  
At some point or other, my parents decided that we should read Stuart Little together. How old was I when that happened? Could this have been before 1960, when my little brother Clark was born? I have no idea now. On the jacket blurb for the book, White was quoted as saying that he'd begun the story as an entertainment for a niece, but that before he'd been able to finish it, she'd grown up and was reading Hemingway. This disarming modesty is characteristic of White; indeed, there probably wasn't a more self-effacing a writer of his stature in the 20th Century. 
  
White grew up in an upper-middle class home in Mt. Vernon, New York. He did a stint in the service before taking a degree at Cornell. Then he worked briefly as a journalist in Seattle, before joining the staff of The New Yorker, in the same year as James Thurber, just after its inception in 1925. He also met and married the recently divorced Katharine S. Angell in 1929, adopting her son Roger. They had one son, Joel, who became a noted designer of yachts in Maine. To judge from period photographs, Katharine was a beautiful woman. As an editor at the magazine, she was largely responsible for setting the standard of taste and the subtle tone it became famous for. For White, who had pretentions as a writer of light verse, and innocent humor pieces, the magazine afforded him the chance to exercise his talents in several directions at once--as humorist, as casual serious topical columnist [The Talk of the Town], as the inventor and author of the "newsbreaks" and, eventually, as a serious political and literary essayist.                 
 
       
 
Perhaps not surprisingly, the story of Stuart Little is an analogue of White's own life story. Born in the city into a comfortable family, Stuart soon feels the irresistible pull of Nature, whereupon he takes his leave of the Little family and sets out on his own in the world. White himself, after spending a little over a decade in the city as a successful periodical writer, grew weary of city life, and longed for the country. Following his instincts, he purchased a salt water farm on the coast of Maine, and he and Katharine began spending longer and longer periods of time there. This period in his life is chronicled in his most ambitious book of expository prose, One Man's Meat [1942, Harper & Brother], a collection of "letters" from the country, which are filled with his experiences and feelings about a rural, agricultural existence. Henry David Thoreau's ghost is a palpable presence throughout. The Whites eventually abandoned the city altogether, and though they both would continue their literary activities for several more decades, this early removal symbolized their semi-"retirement" from the hectic demands of city life, to a more sedate, pastoral existence.   
  
                                                                                    
 
This idealized separation between city and country is the governing trope in White's vision of the world. The quintessential, sophisticated New Yorker nurses a yearning for a simpler, more basic connection to the environment, to the smaller social scale of the country. The elegant, cocktail-sipping essayist prefers finding eggs in the chicken coop on cold Winter mornings. The opera performance may beckon, but that old shake roof on the barn needs patching before next season. This conceit about the gentleman farmer is exploited to the hilt, and forms the conceptual frame within which White's imaginary persona--both in his fictions and in his non-fiction prose--is constructed. White's only truly serious polemic involved his support for the creation and purpose of The United Nations [created in 1945], a series of pieces collected into The White Flag [1946, Houghton Mifflin]. White's earnest optimism may seem naive today, as "little" wars and terrorist attacks seem almost a daily item in international news reports, but White's generation had experienced two world wars, and that seemed ample justification to believe in the possibility of an international body, devoted to preventing conflict and encouraging cooperation around the world. 
  
Maintaining a safe distance from the urban bustle, also enabled White to take a more meditative, objective, relaxed view of important issues. From the remote aspect of his Maine farmhouse, he could mount little campaigns against the erosion of free speech, as in his piece against the underwriting of magazine articles by the Xerox Corporation: "I have great respect for all newspapers and magazines, and this Xerox-Esquire arrangement would mean that any rich corporation or rich individual could pick out a reporter and put $50,000 on him and that would be the end of freedom of the press."
  
My favorite White essay--though I have many--is "Bedfellows"--a piece from 1956, where he recounts the exploits of his late, sometimes lamented pet Dachsund Fred, and in which the ponderous pontifications of Harry S. Truman, Dean Acheson and Adlai Stevenson are played against off against the amusing behavior of a dog:
  
"Fred was a window gazer and bird watcher, particularly during his later years, when hardened arteries slowed him up and made it necessary for him to substitute sedentary pleasures for active sport. I think of him as he used to look on our bed in Maine--an old four-poster, too high from the floor for him to reach unassisted. Whenever the bed was occupied during the daylight hours, whether because one of us was sick or was napping, Fred would appear in the doorway and enter without knocking. On his big gray face would be a look of quiet amusement (at having caught somebody in bed during the daytime) coupled with his usual look of fake respectability. Whoever occupied the bed would reach down, seize him by the loose folds of his thick neck, and haul him painfully up. He dreaded this maneuver, and so did the occupant of the bed. But Fred was always willing to put up with being hoisted in order to gain the happy heights, as, indeed, he was willing to put up with far greater discomforts--such as a mouthful of porcupine quills--when there was some prize at the end. Once up, he settled into his pose of bird watching, propped luxuriously against a pillow, as close as he could get to the window, his great soft brown eyes alight with expectation and scientific knowledge. He seemed never to tire of his work. He watched steadily and managed to give the impression that he was a secret agent of the Department of Justice. Spotting a flicker or a starling on the wing, he would turn and make a quick report. 'I just saw an eagle go by,' he would say, 'It was carrying a baby.' This was not precisely a lie. Fred was like a child in many ways, and sought always to blow things up to proportions that satisfied his imagination and his love of adventure. He was the Cecil B. deMille of dogs. He was a zealot, and saw in every bird, every squirrel, every housefly, every rat, every skunk, every porcupine, a security risk and a present danger to his republic. He had a dossier on almost every living creature, as well as on several inanimate objects, including my son's football. Although birds fascinated him, his real hope as he watched the big shade trees outside the window was that a red squirrel would show up. When he sighted a squirrel, Fred would straighten up from his pillow, tense his frame, and then, in a moment or two, begin to tremble. The knuckles of his big fore-legs, unstable from old age, would seem to go into spasm, and he would sit there with his eyes glued on the squirrel and his front legs alternately collapsing under him and bearing his weight again. I find it difficult to convey the peculiar character of this ignoble old vigilante...."
  
The photo above shows White at his typewriter, with Fred or his predecessor holding court over the proceedings. It takes little imagination to see how the aging politicians and their imprecations and warnings and cautionary predictions fare in comparison to the valiant old vigilante Fred.                 
   
       
  
White and Thurber, shown here in their salad days of the 1920's, did a parody of popular Freudian advice books, entitled Is Sex Necessary? [1929, Harper & Brothers]. Though both began as light-hearted humorists, White became the more serious writer, while Thurber continued to elaborate his sense of the absurd for the rest of his life.
 
The New Yorker, too, grew up eventually, taking on a more staid character, until by the early 1960's, when I first discovered it, it had become an institution, and was more responsible, and dogged, and serious than it had been in the early years. "The world grew up," someone once said, "and a damned shame, too." The world of White's early, lighthearted poems and essays [The Lady is Cold, 1928; Ho-Hum and Another Ho-Hum, 1931-32; Every Day is Saturday, 1934; The Fox of Peapack, 1938; and Quo Vadimus, 1939] seems to exist in a hazy past of innocent amusements, a slowly turning colorful carousel of dogs and sailboats and lady's hats and wacky wisecracks. White's later books--aside from the wildly successful children's titles [Charlotte's Web, 1952 and The Trumpet of the Swan, 1970], are serious essays, like letters from a rich uncle whose leisured regimen requires only of him that he send the occasional update to his extended family of legitimate eavesdroppers. You get the feeling, from White's later work, that he only grudgingly acknowledged the necessity for working, and would much rather have spent his time pottering around the back yard in his civvies. 
  
But White was such a good writer, that he could easily have entertained you even if he was only talking about spider webs in the rafters of his barn, which if you think about it, is sort of what he did. I've never been a big fan of children's literature, generally, but I think Stuart Little will live as long as Mother Goose, or Raggedy Anne, Winnie-the-Pooh, or the Oz books--primarily because it doesn't condescend to its presumed audience. There were those who criticized it, early on, as being too difficult, too "open-ended" and sad, for children. But the best literature communicates to those of all ages with equal pertinence. 

In retrospect, White's career is a record of half-reluctant reassessments, false starts, and forced resolutions. But each stage yielded fruit. He accurately estimated his skills, and made the most of them. He turned his private preoccupations into universal folk-tales, and made himself famous. This from a man whose privateness, modesty and naturally retiring manner seemed more typical of a sort of secular monk, than an elegant thinker. He's a distinctly American type, interested neither in laurels, nor notoriety, nor ostentation. A study of the common man, content to live a quotidian existence, tinkering on projects and inventing practical solutions to everyday problems. But of course he was much more than that--which is the contradiction of his personality.           
     
     

Rabu, 09 Desember 2009

Hawks's Red River - Epic Grandeur in the Western Genre




Red River [United Artists, 1948, filmed in 1946], directed by Howard Hawks, adapted to the screen by Borden Chase from his Saturday Evening Post story, is perhaps Hollywood's major effort at romanticizing the American West, the culmination of 20 years of Western-movie-making. There are many--serious critics among them--who seem to believe that The Searchers [Warner Brothers, 1956, John Ford directing] is John Wayne's premier performance, but I've never been able to understand, or appreciate, this opinion. John Ford's reputation for directing Westerns notwithstanding, Red River is certainly a more ambitious, lyrical and complex piece of cinema than anything Ford ever made.

Red River is the movie that the kids in Larry McMurtry's classic movie adaptation The Last Picture Show [1971, Columbia] screen to commemorate the closing of the local movie theater. No one knows more about the history of the Western genre than McMurtry, and the "last" picture show stands not only for the end of a whole era of Texas romantic nostalgia, but of the end of America's dream of the "olde West." 

       


The attempt to portray the exploits of prairie cattle-ranchers as heroic and picturesque was well-established by the time of the film's production (in 1946), but this was the first instance, really, that sufficient means were employed to bring to full fruition a vision of the sweep and scope of landscape, the size and scale and grandeur of the first cattle drive from Texas [in 1865]. The inspired cinematography and musical score--a great one by Dmitri Tiomkin [High Noon ("Do Not Forsake Me, Oh My Darlin"), The Big Sky, Giant, The Unforgiven, The Friendly Persuasion, as well as the familiar TV shows Wild Wild West,  and Rawhide themes]--hold the sprawling concept together, unifying the action with a mythic trope. 

Following the economic devastation of the Civil War, the market for beef in Texas had deteriorated. Texas had only become a state--was in fact "annexed" by the U.S.--in 1845--before seceding in 1861 as part of the Confederacy. The story, then, takes place right in the middle of a historical turning point, just as the "open range" (and the Mexican "presence") as a concept is being superseded by fixed boundaries and clear jurisdiction (The Compromise of 1850 reconfigured the State of Texas into its present shape). Dunson [John Wayne] and Groot [Walter Brennan] turn South from their westward-bound wagon train to settle in the Texas territory in 1851, and 15 years later begins the tortuous cattle drive--necessitated by the need to transport beef to markets in the North and East, connecting to mid-continental rail line routes--that is the ostensible focus of the narrative. The informal "adoption" of Matt Garth [Montgomery Clift] by Dunson contains all the classic step-relation tensions of illegitimacy, sexual competition, and disputed inheritance. Dunson has lost his sweetheard to an indian raid on the wagon-train he abandoned, and he's the bitter old grieving widower. Later, when Matt falls in love with Tess Millay [Joanne Dru]--in another indian  battle with a wagon-train--Tess offers to sleep with Dunson if he'll give up his vendetta against Matt (who's "stolen" the herd from Dunson in mid-journey). 
 
During the drive, Wayne's portrayal of the hardened older Dunson is the best acting of his career. Only 39 at the time, Wayne's version of a man in his sixties is completely convincing, a leathery old patriarch, a law unto himself, whose meanness and cruelty drive him to acts of unreasonable violence and revenge. As the hardships pile up, and hired hands begin to rebel and leave, Matt finally takes over the drive from a wounded Dunson, who in turn vows to kill Garth when he catches up with him. The tension here seems to transcend their step-parent/foundling relationship: Matt is no longer the sulking young would-be gunfighter, but an adult with a will and purpose of his own, which Dunson refuses to acknowledge. Would the relationship be different had Matt been Dunson's real son?



After the drive finally reaches Abilene, and the herd is sold, the two have their big showdown. In the final scene of the movie, Dunson [Wayne] is bearing down on Matt, preparatory to a gunfight. In the famous sequence, Wayne strides purposefully towards him (to the stentorian chanting music of Tiomkin) , but is interrupted by Cherry Valence [John Ireland], another gun-happy slinger hand whose thrown in with Matt. As Cherry draws on him Wayne wheels, fires, killing Valence, who manages to wound Wayne. Hardly missing a beat, Wayne keeps going, and finally faces Matt, who refuses to draw. Wayne fires several warning shots, but Matt holds his ground. Wayne slugs him a couple of times, then at last Matt hits back, knocking Wayne down. Just as things seem on the verge of tragedy, Tess [Dru] fires a pistol in the air and demands that they stop. In an atmosphere of synthesis and sublimation, as the two exhausted men lie bleeding and disheveled in the dirt, Dunson [Wayne] capitulates to fate, and, in one of cinema's most stirring moments ever, draws a new version of the Red River brand design in the sand, adding Matt's initial to his own on opposite sides of the line signifying the river symbol, concluding with the words "You earned it."
 
             

I can still remember clearly how powerfully that ending struck me when I first saw it in the movie theater as a boy. As the step-son of a much older than usual man, I wanted very much to be worthy of his regard and judgment. Though the terms of that conflict were different, the essential psychological outlines of our relationship were almost identical to those in the movie. I would never succeed in pleasing him sufficiently to deserve the "You earned it" encomium of approval which my oedipal demand required. That I perceived the dialectic in these terms goes a long way towards defining the psychic paradigm the movie explores. Boys wanting to be men; men wanting to be virile; and ultimately men wanting and needing love and confirmation but unwilling to ask for it.    

Senin, 07 Desember 2009

Announcing The Collected Poems of Larry Eigner - Stanford University Press - Jan 2010



Well, it's official!  Stanford University Press has formally announced the January 2010 publication of The Collected Poems of Larry Eigner, which Robert Grenier and I co-edited. A labor of over seven years--which involved the tracking down of obscure publications, pouring over an almost limitless mass of typescripts (some in imprecise versions), the meticulous exact setting of over three thousand poems (to establish reliable texts) whose formal organizations on the page were unique for each poem, and finally the creation of an error-free camera-ready copy transmitted directly to the printer--the finished work will arrive in 4 volumes, totaling 1868 pages. The image above is of the front panel, spine and front flap of the dustwrapper of volume I, whose basic design idea was mine; the succeeding three volume jackets are variations on this first one.       


The image above is the rear panel and rear flap. The whole image can be viewed in expanded form--derived from its original PDF format spread--by clicking on the image below, assuming your computer can display it.

 

The effort to bring this behemoth into existence owes its impetus to Robert Grenier, who pre-visioned the collection two decades ago when he began to assist Larry in establishing accurate, edited copies of his work. As those who would know about Larry's work habits and limitations at his writing desk, the task of undertaking this huge job would have been impossible without Bob's initial effort, over time, to produce over a thousand finished edited typescripts in collaboration with Larry--which constituted the major contribution to our joint labors. 
 
The existing major Eigner archive collections at Kansas and Stanford were both compared with all other known versions of Eigner's work, and thanks are due to the respective staffs of those two institutions, The Green Library at Stanford, and the Kenneth Spencer Library at Lawrence, Kansas. 
 
The project was supported by Larry's Brother (and copyright holder for the Estate) Richard Eigner, who was responsible for bringing Larry to Berkeley from the family home in Swampscott, Massachusetts in 1978; the whole project could not have been completed without his help and encouragement. The Collected Poems is a tribute to the affection and care which characterized the Eigner family's regard for Larry, throughout his life, and it's an inspiration, as well, to those afflicted with disabilities--as to us all!--that through understanding, intellectual and emotional nourishment, they can achieve great things.    
 
For my own part, I'm proud to have been able to contribute my energies and time. It was an adventure! You can't truly know the work of a great writer until you copy-read him for accuracy and content. Our joint hope is that a wider readership will finally be able to share our enthusiasm and wonder at Larry Eigner's poetry, presented for the first time in its entirety. 
 
Stanford University Press, which stood by us despite its present constricted financial standing, deserves everyone's thanks. The Collected Eigner, like the Press's previous five-volume edition of the work of Robinson Jeffers, is a tribute to its commitment to preserving and showcasing significant literary work, despite seemingly insurmountable obstacles. Our editor at Stanford, Norris Pope, was a true prince, throughout our long relationship, extending deadlines, and accommodating our need for more textual space. I can't thank him enough for his generosity, decency, and steadying hand.      
 
For those who may wish to pre-order their copy of the 4-volume set, you may go directly here (http://www.sup.org/book.cgi?id=8058) to Stanford University Press online. At $150 per set, it's a steal!  

Minor White & The Emptiness of Transcendence



I never saw or met Minor White, though there are hundreds--certainly thousands--alive today who did, either as friends, or students, or just stray bodies passing casually through the continuum. As a teacher, as a human being, as an artist, White was highly influential, to judge by what those whose lives were touched by his, or who had the occasion to see or know him directly, have reported.
 
 
 

Therefore, what I know of White, is limited to what I see or deduce from the images he left, and the words that he wrote or what was recorded of what he said. One very clear thing to be derived from White's words and images, was that there was something magical about the process of the transmission of human data via sensitized surfaces, or the symbolic meaning of words (language). For White, images, photographic images, could tell a story. Not the kind of story we think of by "once upon a time" but the very much more mysterious story that is built up out of a sequence of images, taken almost randomly (or not) over time, placed in some particular order, accompanied by titles or bridges or captions.
       


Alfred Stieglitz believed that what we "felt" mentally or emotionally could be visually represented, that there are correspondences in the physical/material world, to feelings and sensations that we may think have no substantiality or basis or consequence, except in our brains. Minor White took this notion to a different level. Whereas Stieglitz would often think of an individual image--static, still, fixed--as being an isolated instance of something, White thought to put multiple images into a kind of series of purposeful sequent parts of a greater whole, perhaps not a development from one time or place to another time or place, but in an abstract circle occurring inside a sort of mental carousel. (Indeed, "carousel" is the word for those old-fashioned circular slide film projector carriages we once used to project positives onto home movie screens.)
       


I have purposely not specifically reproduced one of White's equivalent sequences, because I think there's a value in not slavishly following the narrative that he chose to impose on his individual images. White lived a conflicted existence for most of his adult life. As a closeted homosexual, whose professional career required an official, public persona, much of his instructional effort and aesthetic preoccupation was focused on the alienation between life and medium which characterizes so much artistic compromise. But for White himself, there was an ironic non-disclosure about his own identity which drove his anxiety to "release" the mystical artistic response in photographers. Students and patrons felt an enormous pressure behind his work--a pressure that White himself could never address publicly, because of the contemptible consequences which would have ensued: Loss of job, loss of dignity, loss of reputation.      
  
 

 
White's work as a major theorist of the meaning and function of photography and as an exploration of self in the world, and indeed his own work itself, cannot be correctly understood outside the psychological and mystical dimensions in which he deliberately placed it, even though the separate images themselves stand alone as superior instances of successful vision, of powerful pictures which command our attention and awe. But White's private need to convey the crisis of his own creative secret--his love of men--drove him to make "stories"--barely camouflaged ballads and paeans to men, seen in the context of sequences of compellingly suggestive studies and surrealistic cul-de-sacs.     
   
 

White's big career monograph published during his lifetime--Mirrors, Messages and Manifestations--accurately defines the parameters of his aesthetic: 


Mirrors: What we see in the images we choose to take or to represent our version/vision of the world are like mirrors of who we are, what we see, how we think

Messages: Contained in our choice and realization of specific images are the subtly concealed secrets to our own identity, which--like the little riddles inside fortune cookies--offer clues to our fate, and our private nature

Manifestations: The world reveals to us its meaning through our apprehension of it through our senses--as photographers, that apprehension is visual

   

How we choose to interpret specific images may depend on the depth of our understanding of our own motives, of our relation to the language of visual phenomena; but whatever we may think of them, they exist apart from our ability to give them larger spheres of implication through language or music: Intuitively, we can respond in non-verbal or "emotional" ways to things we cannot explain, or which may affect us on levels we are not sufficiently in touch with to describe rationally.

  
In White's case, the gap between image and meaning, direct image and private secret, was never closed, and remained tacit and undeclared all his life. Thus, the ultimate celebration of private nature--the "coming out" of his desire and joy--could never be achieved, and remained unfulfilled. The sequences thus are only mute testaments to the constriction of his range.
      
 

In literature, implications about the truth of one's preoccupations in life are unavoidable, but in art, they may remain trapped in the ambiguity of messages that the world presents. In landscape photography, the choice of subject--as much as anything else--tends to narrow the available options for expression within a given frame. However we approach subject-matter, our will and identity will be expressed through it, despite whatever pre-ordained, over-arching interpretation or context we may wish to place over it. 

Several of White's injunctions about photographic practice, such as--

Let the subject generate its own photograph. Become a camera.
No matter how slow the film, Spirit always stands still long enough for the photographer it has chosen.
Be still with yourself until the object of your attention affirms your presence.

--clearly express his theoretical approach to image-making. They're intended to release the mental response in the photographer, to remove pre-conceptions and allow feeling and direct interaction with subject-matter to occur, without the interference of a priori rules and habits. 

     

But the riddle of identity is that we can never fully escape ourselves. Indeed, even when we may think we're acting--in some sense or other--"outside" of ourselves, this is only an illusion. The process of choosing, in photography, really plays a larger role in defining meaning and revealing our nature, than in deliberately attempting to "think outside the box" of our mental or emotional personal space.   

 

If, as White seemed to believe, our deepest insights are achieved unconsciously, without our conscious oversight, then what we know and how we act may be of little help in the search for meaning. If knowing--as the oversight that governs--dominates feeling, then it may be that dreams, or seemingly nonsensical or disorganized data or sequences, hold the true keys to personal revelation. 
      
 

But what happens when the truth of one's own nature is known, cherished, but suppressed by the mind? Freud believed that creative freedom was achieved when the contradictions in a life were explored, understood, and ultimately released, either in dreams, or analysis, or in altered behaviors. For White, photography was the medium in which he could explore the suppressed side of his nature. What he found in the world was what he already, intuitively, knew was what he was looking for. Himself.



White's wonderful images are the successful, partial composite of his own personality, the sum of his quest for a defining analogue of identity, in the world. This isn't an accident of fate, or the result of a victory over resistances, but--in White's case--the acceptance of a given set of options, of the conditions of life. The images speak through him, and become thus true transmissions of truth. But that truth will be different for each individual, or applicable in a uniquely useful way. Like Rorschach images, there is no "correct" answer to the question of existence, only touchstones and talismans, windows and mirrors: What we see is already there; "all the questions are answered with their own words"--Gertrude Stein   

Sabtu, 05 Desember 2009

Alien - Bizarre Nightmare of Abhorrent Metaphors





Ridley Scott's masterful sci-fi horror flick [Alien, 1979] succeeds quite nicely as a shock & awe narrative, but it's so much more: An absorbing, symbolic-visual exploration of the birth/death parasitic/symbiotic metaphors that leaves one breathless with alternatives. Camille Paglia once described sexual reproduction in the natural world in terms of plagues and hoards and swarms--which is not how we often think of it in a human context. But aggressive self-preservation and mindless consumption are everywhere we look in the natural kingdom, and there's nothing quite so terrifying as looking with unsentimental eyes at how sex and dominance and the hierarchies of selection are expressed at their most basic, concrete levels.


The highly sophisticated design of this production is in no small part due to the work of H.R. Giger, a Swiss surrealist painter and set designer specializing in weird sci-fi monster images ordinarily associated with genre illustration. Giger, who was brought on board to provide all the basic "monster" visuals, which formed the basis for all the alien and much of the high-tech constructs in the film, inspired the raw sexual templates which drive the narrative's momentum. The producers knew from the beginning that the focus of the story would be not on the actors, but on the meanings and implications of the social and technological ideas revealed in the plot, and appropriately stipulated that all the parts cast would be interchangeable, i.e., "unisex"--with the central characterization leading to a woman (Sigourney Weaver as Ripley, the Warrant Officer). 

The futuristic vision presented is a drab, grey, routine, disorienting mining company's return trip aboard an enormous mining transport ship back to earth. Unlike the pristine, flashy, streamlined world of typical science fiction movies, this world is every bit as gritty and drab as a 19th Century coal mining operation, and the social relationships and conflicts are as familiar as they would be in any business operation. 

The first scenes show an eerie room full of covered sleep pods in which the crew are spending their long inter-galactic journey in a state of suspended animation. They are automatically "awakened" by the ship's computerized guidance system (referred to as "Mother" by the crew members--crucially named "Nostromo"--after Conrad's nautical novel) as a result of an apparent "SOS" transmission picked up from a stray "planetoid". Riding inside the belly of the corporate "Mother"-ship, these employees are sustained by the company, and dependent upon it for their lives (as well as their livelihood). 

The crew of seven are thus interrupted in their journey to investigate the source of the signal. What they discover in this very hostile outland is a derelict space-ship with what appears to be the long-dead remnants of a crew, along with some very weird large eggs on the dark floor of the ship's lower chamber. The interior structure of the ship, in addition to the peculiarly proto-human-like creature "melted" onto the "gunner's" position behind a huge cannon, all have suggestively phallic "erectile" ribs and/or conversely uterine walls. The effect is of an exaggeratedly sexual component, of male dominance gone extreme, or sexual energy taken to a bizarre edge. Upon examining one of the quivering eggs (which suggest carnivorous plant structures!), crew-member Kane bends curiously, perilously close, as one "fetal" form shoots out of the top of an egg straight through his helmet guard, attaching itself to his face! Attempts by the crew--upon bringing the victim onboard over the objections of Ripley whose imprecations to observe the "quarantine" procedures--to remove the thing from Kane's face prove futile (the creature, which holds him in its grip, is "keeping him alive" by artificially respirating him) because its "blood" fluid is composed of corrosive acid! This event suggests a sort of "impregnation" or parasitic "injection" of an "egg" or "seed" inside Kane's body, even of a kind of a-sexual "rape"--perpetrated through the oral cavity (oral penetration?). The creature itself is like a sort of reptile-octopus, with multiple jointed legs, with an underside mouth--with a long tentacular tongue (stinger? ovipositor tube?)--with a pouch-like internal body. As the "host" for the alien's seed (Kane thus "carries" the alien spawn within himself--another sexual reversal) we suspect that whatever transformation may occur within Kane's body will be harmful. Seemingly recovered, as he's sitting at the dinner table with the crew consuming a meal ("last supper") preparatory to going back into the sleep pods for the remainder of the journey, Kane becomes violently sick. As he's thrown onto the table on his back, the alien bursts from his stomach cavity, eating-tearing its way out in a bloody explosive raging Caesarean "birth," killing the mother-host. It "cries" out like a bawling infant, and scurries away to hide.

The ensuing struggle against the alien "inside" the Mother ship, occupies the balance of the action of the movie, complicated by one key sub-plot. It turns out that Ash, the ship's Science Officer, is really an android, whom "the Company" has put on board to engineer the capture and return of the alien. Its motives for wanting to do so remain murky, but it seems to suggest that it wants to harness the alien's power for some nefarious purpose. In the far-distant future, apparently, corporate greed and design is no more public-spirited than it is in our time!

Ripley, who is almost killed by Ash in his attempt to prevent her from scuttling the Mother ship in order to escape from the deadly alien's predation, manages to chop the android's head off, but not before he reveals to her his secret mission as the embedded "mole" of the crew. Before Parker incinerates him, Ash predicts that the other crew members will not survive. Realizing the danger of allowing the alien (like a virus or sinister super-life-form competitor) to be returned to earth, the remaining three crew members plan to arm the Nostromo's self-destruct mechanism and escape in the shuttle, but Parker and Lambert are killed by the Alien while gathering the necessary supplies. Ripley initiates the self-destruct sequence and heads for the shuttle with Jones, the ship's lone pet (a cat), but finds the Alien blocking her way. She unsuccessfully attempts to abort the self-destruct (swearing expletives at "Mother"), then returns to find the alien seemingly gone and narrowly escapes in the shuttle as the Nostromo explodes. Thinking herself at last safe, Ripley disrobes, only to discover--to her horror--that the alien has snuck aboard and is sleeping in a corner of the confined space of the shuttle. She puts on a pressurized space suit and opens the hatch, causing explosive decompression which forces the Alien to the open doorway. She shoots it with a grappling gun, which propels it out, but the gun is caught in the closing door, tethering the Alien to the shuttle. It attempts to crawl into one of the engines, but Ripley activates them and blasts the Alien into space. The film ends with Ripley and Jones entering stasis for the return trip to Earth. 

The design of the alien's body is based on the adaptive power of the beast to take on characteristics of its host-victim. An alien life form based on a different chemical paradigm and that carbon-hydrogen-oxygen protein model, it nevertheless gains by mating its own inherently more powerful survival components with a human structure and brain, becoming a frighteningly efficient killer. The transformational power of the alien suggests the adaptive power of viral agents to mutate into more elaborately elusive entities by "stealing" DNA. But viruses (like the alien itself) aren't truly "life"-forms as we would define them; except in the sense that, not being immortal, they need to reproduce themselves in order to survive. Can a thing which is not "alive" "survive" by exploiting true life forms for its reproduction? Not all parasitic agents cause the demise of their hosts, though there is nothing necessarily "friendly" about anything which can only live through the existence of another. Which is partly the point of all mindless exploitative agencies. If a purely destructive mechanism--such as an efficient soldier, or soldier-ant, or rigidly militaristic-fascist society--runs out of "enemies" or "hosts" then it, too, faces extinction.                                              


The design of the alien creature itself is a fascinating variation on the robot concept. The head of the alien suggests a phallus, but its vicious teeth--and, most interestingly, its compound mouth inside, like a tongue mutated into an "internal" set of jaws--suggest all kinds of metaphors, such as the phallus as sword, phallus as devourer, or collaterally, a vagina-dentata, or a phallus which devours (as in the female spider which eats its mate, or male fathers which kill or eat their young). In the movie, the alien is portrayed as a killing machine, without remorse, without ulterior motive, a kind of clone upon the human (or any available) form, adapting to its hosts in order to mutate over and over into successively more sophisticated forms of animate exploitation. 

The "company's" desire seems the most dominant motive trope in the story. Its human "workers" (as in an ant or termite or bee colony) seem only to exist for the good of the organization, a variation on the corporate paradigm of late 20th Century capitalism. The alien thus becomes a potential managerial super-race (or super class) of hybrid, mechanical managers whose only ultimate function is the perfection of the expanding power of the organization.                

Selasa, 01 Desember 2009

From the Gallery of Heroes: H.L. Mencken

                                                                 H.L. Mencken in his prime

H.L. [Henry Louis] Mencken [1880-1956], was perhaps America's greatest iconoclast--a muckraker, satirist, critic and editor who came to prominence in the heyday of the popular American press--whose powers to offend, incite, provoke, confound, delight and entertain with his audacious wit and ruthless disdain, are unrivaled in the history of American journalism. Lacking a formal university education, Mencken started out as a newspaperman in Baltimore (his home town), but he read voraciously, and eventually became known, due to his erudition, as "the Sage of Baltimore." Mencken loved to make mischief, to stir things up. In the course of his long writing career, he eventually offended just about everyone--and was at the top of every legion of decency's hit list. A proud German-American, who liked beer halls and big cigars, there is a clear German cast to much of his thinking. His first important book was The Philosophy of Freidrich Nietzsche [1907]--in it, he identified with Nietzsche's signature social Darwinism, a sort of caste system of privilege (what Mencken called intellectual "aristocrats") in which the upper and upper-middle classes are imagined to be superior due to their greater aptitude and effort, rather than through accident of birth or financial good luck. Mencken was unquestionably an anti-semite in philosophical disposition, but he wouldn't have gotten this out of Nietzsche, unless he willfully misunderstood him. It's been noted that Mencken in practice was friendly toward Jews, and lobbied on their behalf during the Nazi persecutions, but this ambiguity does not constitute a salvation. Nevertheless, Mencken displayed a stubbornly contradictory attitude, alternately praising and reviling American Negroes and Jews.  

While his career as a journalist continued full-time, he began to publish collections of serious essays--A Book of Burlesques [1916], A Book of Prefaces [1917], In Defense of Women [1917], and six volumes of Prejudices [1919-1927]. Mencken was preoccupied with the perfectibility of man, and hence much of 19th Century thought regarding fitness and purity and achievement interested him. He was anti-Christian, and spent a good deal of energy heaping amused scorn on its followers. He regarded the American South as backward and provincial.       
         

                                      H.L. Mencken and George Jean Nathan by Irving Penn

In the 1920's, Mencken, along with drama critic George Jean Nathan, edited first The Smart Set [under his direction from 1914-1923], and then The American Mercury [founded 1924, until he resigned editorship in 1933]. Both contained fiction, commentary, and humor with subversive and satirical undertones, with by-lines including Eugene O'Neill, Carl Sandburg, William Faulkner, Sinclair Lewis, F. Scott Fitzgerald, Langston Hughes, W.E.B. DuBois, James Weldon Johnson, Conrad AIken, Sherwood Anderson, Edgar Lee Masters, John Fante, William Saroyan, among others. Ever lusting after a good controversy, Mencken traveled to Boston in 1926 in order to be publicly arrested for the sale of the April issue of The American Mercury (containing an "obscene" article about a prostitute). Mencken was tried and acquitted. 
 
In the same year, Mencken's articles about the Scopes "Monkey Trial" in Tennessee, which pitted Clarence Darrow against William Jennings Bryan over the issue of the teaching of evolution in the public schools, became the inspiration for the 1936 play Inherit the Wind, later made into a movie which starred, among others, Gene Kelly as the Mencken-figure E.K. Hornbeck, and Spencer Tracy as the Darrow stand-in Henry Drummond ("We will hang Henry Drummond from the old apple tree!).
 
 
 


My introduction to Mencken was this edition of The American Scene [Knopf, 1965, Edited by Huntington Cairns], which I checked out of the library. Once I'd started it, I couldn't put it down. I recall distinctly sitting on mom's chaise lounge under our fig tree in the afternoon chuckling to myself. As old as the issues and subjects might be that Mencken was talking about, his prose was so boisterous (no other word for it) and fresh that it almost didn't matter whether what he was saying made any sense at all. I also had the distinct feeling--which I suspect was probably something that many of his readers shared--that I belonged in his "aristocracy" of taste and good breeding, an illusion that the tone and address of his writing subtly suggested. Certainly, I didn't think of myself as belonging to the "boob-ocracy"!
 
The great thing about Mencken was his enthusiasm and skepticism. This combination of appetite and disdain, which was always present in his work, has a particularly American flavor, which has always seemed admirable to me. As much as Mencken despised America's provinciality, its naivite, its hucksterism, its petulant bourgeois presumption, at the same time he loved its energy, innocence and joy. This affection is nowhere more evident than in his monumental three volume study of "American" English, The American Language--I put American in quotation marks, since at the time Mencken began his work, there were no officially recognized divisions among English speakers, but his work is a proof--if any were needed--of the uniqueness of American speech, in all its teeming centers, remote outposts, in all its variations of class, race, region, ethnic and obscure coinage. 
 
What immediately becomes apparent to anyone who would undertake to study the peculiar flavor of the language of a people of so large a national mosaic, is that to understand it requires that one comprehend just about everything that people does--their industry, their recreations, their habits, their interests--in short, the whole cross-section of their society and endeavor. No one who was not fascinated and intrigued and delighted by his subject, could have brought it off.  
              


You could with justice say that Mencken was somewhat un-American in his personal philosophy, that he didn't really subscribe to the true democratic ideals that form the basis of our national character. In reading over this quotation--

"Democracy gives the beatification of mediocrity a certain appearance of objective and demonstrable truth. The mob man, functioning as citizen, gets a feeling that he is really important to the world—that he is genuinely running things. Out of his maudlin herding after rogues and mountebanks there comes to him a sense of vast and mysterious power—which is what makes archbishops, police sergeants, the grand goblins of the Ku Klux and other such magnificoes happy. And out of it there comes, too, a conviction that he is somehow wise, that his views are taken seriously by his betters—which is what makes United States Senators, fortune tellers and Young Intellectuals happy. Finally, there comes out of it a glowing consciousness of a high duty triumphantly done which is what makes hangmen and husbands happy."

--it occurred to me that this could serve as a very prescient comment upon the political career of George W. Bush, especially that part about a "glowing consciousness of a high duty triumphantly done" which seemed to characterize Dubya's Alfred E. Neuman smirk at the end of each of his speeches. Mencken saw in the typical American populist office-seeker the "man who is, intrinsically, the most devious and mediocre — the man who can most easily adeptly disperse the notion that his mind is a virtual vacuum." 
                                                                           
Mencken published three volumes of his memoirs during the early 1940's, but much of his colorful biographical writings had to wait several decades to be published, due to their inflammatory content. Mencken's publisher, Alfred A. Knopf, recalled his Author's "brightly colored pajamas, his devotion to his mother, his gusto at the piano, his fear of air travel." He praised Mencken's taste in books and chuckled over his blatant disregard for Prohibition and despite his reputation "of being a burly, loud, raucous fellow, rough in his speech and lacking refined manners, as [he] learned a little later, displayed the most charming manners conceivable in talking with women. His public side was visible to everyone: tough, cynical, amusing, and exasperating by turns, but everlastingly consistent. The private man was something else again: sentimental, generous, and unwavering—sometimes almost blind—in his devotion to people he liked." Mencken's articles over the course of a long career suggest that his dislikes were many: Christians, Jews, President Roosevelt, the American public itself. If Mencken had any moral principle at the base of his prickly prose, it was a brand of libertarianism that, for him, was close to a religion. Nothing seemed to matter more to him than uncensored self-expression--an attitude which may explain my own peremptoriness in print! He did not always win friends, nor did he set any standards for politically correct journalism. But he remains a legend among American writers, and his words are unlikely to be forgotten.